Discussion in 'The National Football League' started by infantrycak, Mar 17, 2010.
Virtually move down a round, give up a 3rd and $5 mil per year? Mmmmkay.
He's a developmental quarterback but could this possibly mean that Pete Carroll is assuming the Rams are taking Bradford and that Jimmy Clausen isn't worth drafting?
I say they overpaid for Whitehurst but if he turns out like Matt Schaub (who at least played with the Falcons) then they've got a steal. Right now I'm scratching my head, but if Carroll knows what he's doing then so be it.
Did Seattle hire Asserly or something?
That's the thing, he was a 3rd round pick to begin with. He has since attempted 0 NFL passes and somehow his value is increased? Schaub had at least flashed brilliance.
Whitehurst was touted as a developmental QB with all the right skills and had a strong arm. I think this is a good move by the Seahawks to get a guy that can start if Hasselbeck goes down or can start next year. Seahawks can now focus on OL/DL.
Why did the Seahawks have to agree to a trade if he was a RFA? Couldn't they have just offered up more cash this year (no cap) to assure the Chargers wouldn't match, or make it incentive based in year 2 that would allow him to make more cash than the Chargers could afford? Either way the Chargers are set with their 1st 2 picks coming within the top 40. Some teams have all the luck
If he was an RFA, that doesn't mean that the Chargers just had right of first refusal. The Chargers put a draft pick tender on him so the Seahawks negotiated that pick. For example, someone could sign Demeco away from us right now. They'd just have to give us a 1st round and a 3rd round pick to do it and then we could still match the offer (I believe.) In this case, Whitehurst had some sort of draft pick tender and the Seahawks negotiated the draft picks to something other than what the original tender was.
Whitehurst got the original round tender from the Chargers. The Seahawks don't have a third this year, so he signed with the Chargers who then traded him for next years third rounder and swapped positions in the second to cover the cost of the 3rd being a year off.
I guess if you want a QB who looks like one of the Bee Gee's, you gotta pay for it!
Thanks for the clarification...
He was a hot prospect in college, an injury moved him down to the 3rd round.
Not a bad pick up for the Seachickins, but the deal looks pretty wonky to me. Talk about a high risk/reward type deal.
As far as the salary...I think when we said Orlovsky's 3 year $9 million deal was overpaying, we were using old standards. I think the new standard is $15 million for stars, $3-$4 million for backups. In this case, it's pretty clear they like Whitehurst as a potential starter.
I think Whitehurst will start in 2011 or possibly sooner if MH gets hurt
So Carroll has traded one of his (if not the) best d-linemen for peanuts and gave up draft picks and 5mil a year for a guy who has 0 NFL passes attempted.
I hear ya, but what were the Seahawks doing that was so special now?
Might as well let Carroll do his thing and see what happens. Or they can keep all the same players and see if they can be dead last in their division again.
How pissed would you be if we traded draft picks for. . . Charlie Batch? Actually no that wouldn't be accurate because Batch has thrown passes in the NFL. Okay how about John Parker Wilson? I understand letting the new coach do his thing or whatever, but honestly these moves seem rather silly, giving up Darryl Tapp for Chris Clemons (Who?) and a fourth.
I mean yeah, the Sehawks weren't great last year (I think their entire O-line was injured at some point and they had Seneca Wallace starting for some games), but it's kind of silly to trade your only good D-lineman as well as some draft picks to get a guy who was a 3rd stringer. Draft picks for a 3rd stringer.
Of course now that I've done some reading I've read that the 'Hawks actually got SD's 3rd this year, and gave up their 3rd next year and swapped 2nds this year, which isn't nearly as bad.
I want to know why the Texans didn't swing a deal like this with them for John David Booty. That would be awesome.
Well, Pete Carroll can deal with Whitehurst as if he WAS a first round draft pick. So, does this mean that with the two picks they have they will go OT and RB or defense?
I think they go OL and DL
Separate names with a comma.