Discussion in 'College Football & the NFL Draft' started by bah007, Nov 20, 2007.
Who should win?
Rec. Yds. TDs
Crabtree - 125 1861 21
Manningham - 67 1096 11
Nelson - 107 1441 10
Texas Tech always gives an unfair advantage for QB's and WR's because the pass SO much.
With that said...Crabtree is absolutely amazing and will be a very very high pick in the '09 draft. I take crabtree over any wr in the nation
Who has consistently played the best against top competition?
IMO Manningham prolly deserve it more playing on a team that has had injuries at QB,h as often been forced to stick to a more running game and put up impressive numbers despite that gives him my vote for what that counts.
Crabtree no doubt. clearly the best.
Manningham is nothing.
manningham sucked vs. ohio state, and crabtree has been playing great all year, although they pass 70 times a game. But, still gotta give it to crabtree.
Crabtree, but my opinion is biased seeing as how I'm a student at Texas Tech. As far as speed goes he's nothing special, but he is the mast of yards after catch. I don't think I've ever seen a WR break so many tackles and make so many people miss.
Crabtree. The guy is nasty. Next Chad Johnson.
Separate names with a comma.