This is my review of what the Texans need based on my perception of their quality of talent at each position (if you want the backups all listed, help yourself). Please chime in with corrections and your opinions on rankings.
[1=we have no talent, 2=we need to improve, 3=poor man's starter and we should try to improve, 4=decent/average NFL starter that is more than sufficient, 5=above average talent, 6=stud or forget about improving this without a trade]
QB - Carr 6 - He is the guy, for better or worse.
RB - DomDavis, Hollings 4 - The jury is still out, but it looks good.
But, it may be a need next year.
WR1- AJ 6 - Stud
WR2- ? 1 - Our backups lack talent.
If not addressed in FA, a major need.
WR3- Gaffney, Armstrong 4 - These guys are solid #3s, just not 2s.
TE - Joppru/Bruener/Miller 3 - Wait and see for one more year?
OLT- Wand 2 - Our BIGGEST weakness at a critical spot.
OLG- Pitts 3 - ?
C - McKinney 3 - ?
ORG- Washington 3 - ?
ORT- Wade 5 - super solid
P- Stanley 4 -solid
K- Brown 5- more than solid
Return Specialists- Moses 2 - (maybe a 1) Moses is not hacking it.
SS- Earl 4 (based on potential)
FS- Simmons 3 - ?
RCB- Dunta 6 - stud
LCB- Glenn 5/2 - Gleen is strong
(but we need to develop a backup)
ROLB- Peek 2 - might be an argument here
(but he is only potential at this time)
ILB1- Greenwood 3 - we hope he is a 4
ILB2- Wong 3 - again, we hope he is a 4
LOLB- Babin 4 (based on potential)
DLT- Walker 4 - but paid like a 5, need depth
NT- Payne 4 - but paid like a 5, need depth
DRT- RSmith 4 - but paid like a 5, need depth
NICKEL CB- Faggins 3 - sufficient
I am not sure about a few of these guys, like Simmons, Earl and Greenwood. But, it looks like they are sufficient.
Based on my perception, our biggest needs are WR2 (ranked 1), ROLB (ranked 2) and OLT (ranked 2).
At the same time, we need to draft depth at OL interior and DL.
Also, we need to draft a CB to replace Glenn.
Beyond that, we need ILB to develop.
Based on everyone else's top 13 mocks, we should be able to choose a BAP that fills one of these needs.
Top 11 guys that will be gone [QB -Rodgers/ASmith, RB- Benson/CWilliams/Brown, LB - DJ/Merriman, CB - Rolle/Jones, WR - Williams/Edwards] If any of these slip, I think we have to take them (except QB) (and yes, that applies even to a RB)
So, assuming noone slides, starting at 13 we have to pick from the not so highly ranked next group.
If the top 11 are gone, I hope we trade down. If I were sold on Williamson, he would be the guy. I hate to draft a DL in the first for him to be a bu and the other OLBs do not seem worthy of the pick. I say trade down, get an extra 2nd and/or 3rd to round out our need for depth.
[1=we have no talent, 2=we need to improve, 3=poor man's starter and we should try to improve, 4=decent/average NFL starter that is more than sufficient, 5=above average talent, 6=stud or forget about improving this without a trade]
QB - Carr 6 - He is the guy, for better or worse.
RB - DomDavis, Hollings 4 - The jury is still out, but it looks good.
But, it may be a need next year.
WR1- AJ 6 - Stud
WR2- ? 1 - Our backups lack talent.
If not addressed in FA, a major need.
WR3- Gaffney, Armstrong 4 - These guys are solid #3s, just not 2s.
TE - Joppru/Bruener/Miller 3 - Wait and see for one more year?
OLT- Wand 2 - Our BIGGEST weakness at a critical spot.
OLG- Pitts 3 - ?
C - McKinney 3 - ?
ORG- Washington 3 - ?
ORT- Wade 5 - super solid
P- Stanley 4 -solid
K- Brown 5- more than solid
Return Specialists- Moses 2 - (maybe a 1) Moses is not hacking it.
SS- Earl 4 (based on potential)
FS- Simmons 3 - ?
RCB- Dunta 6 - stud
LCB- Glenn 5/2 - Gleen is strong
(but we need to develop a backup)
ROLB- Peek 2 - might be an argument here
(but he is only potential at this time)
ILB1- Greenwood 3 - we hope he is a 4
ILB2- Wong 3 - again, we hope he is a 4
LOLB- Babin 4 (based on potential)
DLT- Walker 4 - but paid like a 5, need depth
NT- Payne 4 - but paid like a 5, need depth
DRT- RSmith 4 - but paid like a 5, need depth
NICKEL CB- Faggins 3 - sufficient
I am not sure about a few of these guys, like Simmons, Earl and Greenwood. But, it looks like they are sufficient.
Based on my perception, our biggest needs are WR2 (ranked 1), ROLB (ranked 2) and OLT (ranked 2).
At the same time, we need to draft depth at OL interior and DL.
Also, we need to draft a CB to replace Glenn.
Beyond that, we need ILB to develop.
Based on everyone else's top 13 mocks, we should be able to choose a BAP that fills one of these needs.
Top 11 guys that will be gone [QB -Rodgers/ASmith, RB- Benson/CWilliams/Brown, LB - DJ/Merriman, CB - Rolle/Jones, WR - Williams/Edwards] If any of these slip, I think we have to take them (except QB) (and yes, that applies even to a RB)
So, assuming noone slides, starting at 13 we have to pick from the not so highly ranked next group.
If the top 11 are gone, I hope we trade down. If I were sold on Williamson, he would be the guy. I hate to draft a DL in the first for him to be a bu and the other OLBs do not seem worthy of the pick. I say trade down, get an extra 2nd and/or 3rd to round out our need for depth.