We are quick to say Mario needs time to develop and he does. All three of the top picks that year are still kids playing a man's game. We forget how young these kids are.
Mario is learning. He is excellent against the run but I think he's being used wrong. Its obvious he either needs to stand up, or be playing on the left side. I sometimes wonder if we're misusing him or trying to cover for the lack of ability for our OLBs to play the run. I think he'll develop into a nice player.
Overall I don't know if any of the 3 were the best player in the draft. I'd say they all have amazing potential and you really can't knock anyone for taking any of them. Enough of the "our guy is better than theirs"... lets just worry about who we're playing next
Mike
Recently, I wrote about the Chronicle draft redo:
The 2006 NFL Redraft: Who's Your Pick?
You know, after looking at it some, I'm not sure anyone is worth the first pick money. Marketingwise, VY would have been a nice short term pick because there are a bunch of 7 year olds in Houston trying to figure out what NFL player to idolize.
Fitwise, I'm not sure that VY would have been a good fit with Kubiak, but you never know. Also, VY as a Texans would have instantly become the most powerful figure in sports. That's a dangerous thing if that power comes before NFL performance--you know, if he doesn't succeed it isn't his fault, it's his coaches. And if there are already whispers about him and his maturity level, do you think it would be any easier to control him in Houston?
In any event, your comment about how young they are is well taken. Mario Williams came out of school not only as a junior, but a true junior. He was so physically gifted that I think that his technique lagged due to coaches just trying to get him on the field as much and as fast as possible, technique be damned.
I like Mario's upside assuming he stays healthy. He has a learning attitude with his coaches and doesn't have a big head. (If anything, he needs to develop more confidence).
I think the way he is being used is partially a response to where Anthony Weaver (and his big contract) can play.