Here's a question for you. What safeties in the NFL would you trade the #9 pick in the draft for? Give a yay or nay to the following:
Ed Reed
Troy Polamalu
Sean Taylor
Donte Whitner
Roy Williams
Sean Jones
Kerry Rhodes
Bob Sanders
Chris Hope
Brian Dawkins
John Lynch
Adrian Wilson
Michael Huff
I ask because these are your best safeties in the NFL, at the moment. And honestly? There is only ONE guy on that list I would consider trading a #9 pick for and that is Ed Reed.
And you know what's funny about that? Even Baltimore didn't know they were drafting Ed Reed when they drafted Ed Reed. They got him at pick #24 in the draft. And you know one thing about Ed Reed? He ain't that fast. He barely cracked a 4.57, at 5'11" and 201 pounds.
I think the NFL is going through a bit of a phase right now with fast safeties. Everyone are in love with these super fast safeties, love the idea of guys that have such big range that they can paint that center field. Hey, we fell for it too. We got Jason Allen. You know what the thing about that is?
Forgetting a classic rule of football personnel. The closer you get to the middle of the hash marks, the less important speed is in the priority chain. If you want a rangey centerfielder, you can get one and you don't need to spend a #9 pick. If you want a power packin playmaker at centerfielder, you go find that power packin playmaker, and stop worrying so much about 4.3 speed.
And to me, that power packin playmaker at centerfield has been Reggie Nelson...since halfway into the college season. He's the intimidator, he's the guy that makes all the plays on the ball. I guess it's a bonus that he's got some range on him, but I wouldn't really mind if he ran a 4.5 or so.
So why are we talking about paying a top 10 pick for Landry? Because he ran a 4.3? On the field, you can give me Brandon Merriweather or Reggie Nelson as easily as you give me LaRon Landry. Am I so very positive that Landry's going to be the next Ed Reed and not those guys? Answer is no. So why the top 10 for Landry when you can get the other dudes much later?
Overall, the only time I'd ever suggest the use of a top 15 pick on a safety...would be if the rest of the prospects just pretty much suck.