Death to Google Ads! Texans Talk Tip Jar! 🍺😎👍
Thanks for your support!

Do you want DC to be the starting QB next season?

Do YOU want Carr to start here in Houston next season?

  • Yes

    Votes: 88 41.1%

  • No

    Votes: 126 58.9%
  • Total voters
    214
G

gtexan02

Working?
Don't make this complicated. Just a simple yes or no will do. I'm trying to guage support for something. This shouldn't be a debate, or hypothetical. Just yes or no.
 
Nope.

But wait a little while and the California Carr Cult will stop by with some excuses, alibis, blame shifting and derogatory remarks about possible replacements.
 
No..ive already stated my position in previous threads. Its nothing against David.. we just need to go in a different direction to shake this air of "loser" that is hanging over the team as a whole.
 
Ridiculous question.

No one in his/her right mind would want a sixth year of David Carr.


HEY! SIX FREAKING YEARS? ARE YOU KIDDING?
 
No way .

MINNEAPOLIS (Feb. 28, 2007) -- In a long-expected move, the Minnesota Vikings released quarterback Brad Johnson and made the 15-year veteran an unrestricted free agent.

Tarvaris Jackson, who started the final two games of last season as a rookie, and Brooks Bollinger are the only quarterbacks remaining on the roster.
 
HoustonFrog said:
So 2 players say it is time to make a move, etc and people still think it is a good idea to keep him?OK..lol
Click to expand...

Don't forget that the coach took the ball out of his hands for our last three wins.

& our GM said we are not pleased with what we got from our QB in '06.
 
thunderkyss said:
Don't forget that the coach took the ball out of his hands for our last three wins.

& our GM said we are not pleased with what we got from our QB in '06.
Click to expand...

EXACTLY TK. I'll just report what I put in another thread....

Forget what they are looking for as a replacement for a second.....you have D'Rob saying "It's time.......I'm not saying he can't be a great QB with another team. But here has been here 5 years and the best we have been able to do is 7-9." You also have Moulds saying, "the quarterback has to show he can carry (the team.)" It is amazing that they can express things alot of people here have been saying for a while yet people want to keep him. Add to that the fact that management has already shown a willingness to let him go and many fans are ready and you have a situation where it is imperative that he be let go in a trade or some type of deal. He's lost fans, teammates and a team's managements faith. It iS time.
 
I'm just surprised there are still 40% of us that want Carr back. I actually think it is better for David to get a clean slate with a new team. It just isn't a good situation for him here any more.
 
I'd love to hear the positives for bringing him back. What does he bring to the field that we can't get out of Sage.. BVP.. hell Quinton Porter for that matter.
 
HoustonFrog said:
EXACTLY TK. I'll just report what I put in another thread....

Forget what they are looking for as a replacement for a second.....you have D'Rob saying "It's time.......I'm not saying he can't be a great QB with another team. But here has been here 5 years and the best we have been able to do is 7-9." You also have Moulds saying, "the quarterback has to show he can carry (the team.)" It is amazing that they can express things alot of people here have been saying for a while yet people want to keep him. Add to that the fact that management has already shown a willingness to let him go and many fans are ready and you have a situation where it is imperative that he be let go in a trade or some type of deal. He's lost fans, teammates and a team's managements faith. It iS time.
Click to expand...

Just curious, are these actual quotes or are you paraphrasing?
 
thunderkyss said:
Don't forget that the coach took the ball out of his hands for our last three wins.

& our GM said we are not pleased with what we got from our QB in '06.
Click to expand...

And that will be the situation for all of '07 if we were to keep DC.
A multi-million dollar QB with his hands tied to keep him from hurting his team's chances of winning.
 
HoustonFan said:
Yes. Who else is available othern than Jeff Garcia and Jake Plummer? Not too sure about either of these guys.
Click to expand...

this is how i feel..i dont really want to keep carr but given whats out there- i dont see a big improvement so i said yes
 
I want whatever is best for the Texans.

I'm not someone who wants to ditch DC at any cost. For me, the answer depends on the options. I don't want to break the bank for Plummer or give away too much value to get him.

And I would like for there to be a legit competition for QB.
 
don't forget to factor in that Carr's friends & family are on here bailing water from a sinking ship.
 
i dont understand the need to create a thread when alot of us know how everybody else feels. i dont support DC coming back, but i am not going to start ANOTHER thread on the subject. you are just going to have the same people saying the same thing on the same subject. you could just sift through the other threads about DC to find the same amount of disdain. just beating a dead horse if you ask me.

i agree with chick, i'll support whatever the football people think is best for the football team.
 
The only people that you will find want David Carr to start are a select few on this message board. If this poll was given to the general public, it wouldn't even be as close as it is now.

Yeah, my answer is no.
 
Of course I voted yes, due to the fact that there is no-one available that comes close to Carr's numbers, so if you want a trade it will be a trade DOWN, and what's the point in that? Unrelated-Wiegert & Moulds were cut, I think it's a start, and Payne on D, that's been a long time coming IMO. I still see too much focus on Carr, Evans burned a CB twice in the first quarter for over 160 yards, why not pick on the CB that doesn't cover or learn, or the line that let VY run for a 39 yard TD in OT, or what was the 30th ranked defense in the NFL. We need to focus on the biggest problem first, our defense, not looking for the easiest scape goat. This thread sounds like a broken record, Get rid of Carr, anyone but Carr !, that way ya'll get what you want, and when it fails ya'll can say " Their the coaches they should have known". Back your QB he is the best avaiable. 2 cents-Manning was on the Colts that won the SB-Does that make him the best QB in the NFL this year? And Rex Grossman was on the Bears that won the National conference but lost in the SB, does that make him the second best QB in the NFL?
 
srstex said:
Of course I voted yes, due to the fact that there is no-one available that comes close to Carr's numbers, so if you want a trade it will be a trade DOWN, and what's the point in that? Unrelated-Wiegert & Moulds were cut, I think it's a start, and Payne on D, that's been a long time coming IMO. I still see too much focus on Carr, Evans burned a CB twice in the first quarter for over 160 yards, why not pick on the CB that doesn't cover or learn, or the line that let VY run for a 39 yard TD in OT, or what was the 30th ranked defense in the NFL. We need to focus on the biggest problem first, our defense, not looking for the easiest scape goat. This thread sounds like a broken record, Get rid of Carr, anyone but Carr !, that way ya'll get what you want, and when it fails ya'll can say " Their the coaches they should have known". Back your QB he is the best avaiable. 2 cents-Manning was on the Colts that won the SB-Does that make him the best QB in the NFL this year? And Rex Grossman was on the Bears that won the National conference but lost in the SB, does that make him the second best QB in the NFL?
Click to expand...
thank you--
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top