don't know. once they get to the Pros, it's not so much about talent as it is heart. He's going to be getting his butt tagged on a play by play basis, and everything is going to be happening much faster than it did in college. Depending on how he handles those two things.... being mentally & physically tough, willing to get back up, and play some football, and adjusting to the speed of the game.
For all I know, NCAA was slow for Vince, and Jay was comfortable. So coming to the NFL, things are happening at a good speed for Vince, and a little fast for Jay.... so it might take him longer.
If it were the other way around, Jay will be ready for the play-offs.
I understand that you all have probably seen Vince play a little more than I have, so I am not going to argue with you about Vince. Also, I know that Vince did it once with the Titans this last week, that doesn't make it true yet. But, I guarantee you that jay was more than comfortable in the college game. Perhaps I am a bit of a "homer" as is the term so frequently used on this board, but I graduated at the same time as Cutler, took classes with him, did group projects with him, and watched all of his games as a fan. The guy is as calm and collected as can be. He may make mistakes, but he will not sweat any of them. And, unless you watched the Vanderbilt - Tennessee, Vanderbilt - Arkansas, or Vanderbilt - Florida games (I count the last one, because even the National Press said that the refs screwed Vandy over), you can't possibly know what I mean when I say that he lead Vanderbilt.
Also, how many of Vince's teammates from last year are in the NFL this year? I'll go ahead and venture that it is more than 0. Cutler was the only Vanderbilt player drafted last year, only 3 others were invited to camp, and only one made it past the 75 person cut. I say all of that, because there is a larger desparity between the bad and the good teams in college ball, where as in the NFL, the talent is more spread out, and even the terribly awful teams have a chance to beat the great ones.
And, it doesn't matter where the Titans were predicted to be at the beginning of the season, because even if they kept Volek and he started throughout the year, they would more than likely end up with a better record than the Texans. I say that, not as a bad fan, but merely because pre-season polls and rankings mean nothing.
If any of you have read this far, thank you.