Dude, I gave Carr props, I think he's playing very well, but if you don't think his numbers are somewhat skewed I don't know what to tell you. He does have a great 1st and 4th quarter passer rating, but he got 3 TD's playing against a prevent D in the 4th quarter against Indi. If he could get that kind of production out of his few opportunities in the 2nd and third quarters when the game was still in reach then he'd be getting alot more praise. It's difficult to put up great numbers when you only touch the ball once a quarter, but if he doesn't find a way to be productive then, when the game is still on the line, then those late minute TD drives will only look nice in the stats column. If I'm correct he has 2 TD's (both on opening drives) in the 1st quarter, and 4 in the 4th. Without some help from the running game we're dead meat if he can't learn how to turn it up during the flow of the game.
I love David Carr..... one day, I hope other fans will be saying, but so & so (their QB) doesn't do XXXXX (whatever) Like David Carr does... he puts his team in a situation to win, he makes things happen when there is nothing there.
As far as I can tell, the QB rating is saying that he isn't giving the game away. that he isn't losing the game. He's completing more passes than not, He's throwing more TDs than INTs. I don't have any problem with David's QB rating, I don't believe they are skewed.
What people think about QB rating is a bit skewed. Charlie Batch could step in for BigBen, for one Qtr. throw a couple of completions, and a TD, and his rating would be higher. It doesn't mean he is a better QB.
I think David leaves big plays on the field. I was very critical of David, because he played most of last year scared.... understandably, he had good reason. But I've never seen a QB get to that level, and come back. David, so far IMHO, has done something Jake hasn't. When the Pressure is on, David is still standing in the pocket looking downfield, even though he is getting sacked with the same consistency as previous years, and from my point of view, it isn't getting any better. So Kudos to David...... I firmly believe now, that he is as mentally tough, as he is physically.
When Kubiak says that he needs David to play all 4 Qtrs like he has the 1st & 4th Qtrs, I think that is what he means...... getting those big plays, and not settling for the underneath route, or the dump-off. AJ & Eric are big fast recievers. The guys who can run with them are too small to challenge the ball, with proper placement. The guys who can match them physically are too slow to keep up. Same thing with Putz......
Against Washington, David did a good job of getting the WRs involved early in the game. Yesterday against Miami, I think he did about the same. Not bad by any means........ taking what the defense gave him.
I can't think of any big plays that he missed against Miami, but I think his ball placement was where he could have played better.