Death to Google Ads! Texans Talk Tip Jar! 🍺😎👍
Thanks for your support!

Barry Sanders or John Elway?"

barry sanders or michael bishop?
gale sayers or kordell stewart?
marshall faulk or tim couch?
ladanian tomlinson or alex smith?
 
Barry Sanders or John Elway?
Gale Sayers or Steve Young?
LT or Cunningham?

1 guy who will probably be pretty good or Another guy who will probably be pretty good.
 
kastofsna said:
barry sanders or michael bishop?
gale sayers or kordell stewart?
marshall faulk or tim couch?
ladanian tomlinson or alex smith?
Click to expand...

you forgot a couple

desmond howard or joe montana
brian westbrook or steve young
ki-jana carter or steve mcnair
rahsaan salaam or ben rothliesberger

or my personal favorite
reggie bush or vince young (since you can't compare either one
 
Frank_The_Tank said:
Did you guys know that Reggie Bush and Marshall Faulk put up almost the same marks in their pro day's.
Click to expand...

Yea. I would love to have the next Barry Sanders or Marshall Faulk on our team. I don't think Vince can be compared to anyone but Mike Vick, though... since everyone is so pumped about his speed. Take that away and Vince wouldn't even make the top 10. We would either be arguing Leinart vs. Bush, or there would be no argument what-so-ever.
 
kastofsna said:
how does bush compare to carter or salaam?
Click to expand...
College RBs - Check
First round draft picks - Check
Heisman trophy winner - Check (Salaam was...Carter should've been)

How does Young compare to the QBs you mentioned?

See how this works?
 
actually they compare favorably well. either scrambling/athletic QBs (bishop, stewart) or QBs who succeeded in a ridiculous college offense and were drafted based on that more than their actual abilities (couch, smith). carter and salaam are pretty much nothing like bush, and had careers shortened by injuries and other issues. not a good comparison, but whatever. splittin' hairs i suppose.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top