I am one of the
majority around here who like DD and think he has done a lot of good for the team.
I think that the bulk of the DD bashing comes from a very vocal few, and many of them are just RB people plain and simple.
Two points that I think are worth keeping in mind are:
1) DD's well documented reputation as a player who is an injury concern. Notice I didn't go as far as to say injury prone.
2) Larry Johnson was considered a luxury pick by many because the Cheifs had Priest. Many people questioned that pick when it was made.
I think we can all agree that the Chiefs made the right move with LJ. I know that the two situations are different, but there are similarities.
Also, I was around in the late 80's when Cincy had James Brooks and Icky Woods. Two different style backs who split time/played in the backfield at the same time for the entire year (minus 1 game Brooks missed).
1988 Cincinnati Bengals
+----------------------+----+-----------------------+----------------------+
| Name | G | RSH YARD AVG TD | REC YARD AVG TD |
+----------------------+----+-----------------------+----------------------+
| James Brooks | 15 | 182 931 5.1 8 | 29 287 9.9 6 |
| Ickey Woods | 16 | 203 1066 5.3 15 | 21 199 9.5 0 |
+----------------------+----+-----------------------+----------------------+
2483 total yards and 29 TDs between them is pretty good. If Brooks had played the 16th game, he might have broken 1,000yds rushing as well.
This comparison may or may not seem relative to you all, but I thought it was an awsome (80's vernacular) combination, and one that DD and RB could surpass if used correctly.
http://www.pro-football-reference.com/teams/cin1988.htm