Considering we are 2-14, that's terrible. I'm not a Carr hater, I think he has some talent, but I don't think we will see that talent until he goes to another team. He's big, he's fast - he shouldn't be getting hit every other down, I don't care if the o-line does suck. He doesn't trust our WR's and he's not willing to put the ball in the air and let them do their job. I think Carr can be a good QB for another team, but I think he will struggle with sack issues and decision making for his entire career. With that being said you need a strong o-line and good recievers (two of our biggest weaknesses) to offset Carr's problems.
The biggest reason to take VY - So the Titans don't. I don't want our road to the playoffs to travel through Manning, Leftwich, and Young. Talk about a tough six games every year...