TimeKiller
Guest
Why is it a no-go for Barwin to "leap" over the lineman "in the interest of player safety" but it's perfectly fine for a RB to dive over the line to get a TD or a WR to stick the ball out and knock a pylon over, diving his way out?? Seems like the latter is at least as dangerous as trying to block a kick. You also see plenty of guys dive after a ball on the ground, hell, as far as I know football is responsible for dog-piles...guys LEAPING on top of each other...so what's the deal?
While I'm on a rules rant, how unbelievably lame is forward progress? If you keep churning your feet, I say spot the ball where it went down...not leaving it up to a ref to make some imaginary line where he thinks it was before the ball carrier was pushed back. You want the spot where you got stood up? Go down and get it. Trying for more? Effort is nice but I don't think the refs should recognize effort with a few extra yards.
There's a tie-in to the leaping thing as well, like I was saying, ball carriers dives at a pylon (which technically, isn't that lined up out of bounds?) for a score. Doesn't actually get in the endzone, in fact, he purposefully leaps out of bounds, taking down an object whose purpose is to declare boundary. Forward progress says he broke the plane, it's a score. Really?
I think the league would do well to even up some of this crap in favor of the defense. The rules are so incredibly geared to proping up an offense anyway, I doubt it would even make much of a difference other than to save my sanity every so often lol...
While I'm on a rules rant, how unbelievably lame is forward progress? If you keep churning your feet, I say spot the ball where it went down...not leaving it up to a ref to make some imaginary line where he thinks it was before the ball carrier was pushed back. You want the spot where you got stood up? Go down and get it. Trying for more? Effort is nice but I don't think the refs should recognize effort with a few extra yards.
There's a tie-in to the leaping thing as well, like I was saying, ball carriers dives at a pylon (which technically, isn't that lined up out of bounds?) for a score. Doesn't actually get in the endzone, in fact, he purposefully leaps out of bounds, taking down an object whose purpose is to declare boundary. Forward progress says he broke the plane, it's a score. Really?
I think the league would do well to even up some of this crap in favor of the defense. The rules are so incredibly geared to proping up an offense anyway, I doubt it would even make much of a difference other than to save my sanity every so often lol...