How does this guy fall all the way to the 5th round ? I mean I'm not saying he should have been taken in the first round or even the second round, but all the way to the 5th round ? He's got mobility, descent arm-strength, and accuracy, and size. He's also an experienced QB as he was a multi-year starter, 4 years as a starter I'm thinking ? Don't get it ?
I've been rewatching Bill Walsh QB's drill video with Montana (which includes game footage of each of the throws in the drills).
And I rewatched some of ates' college game tapes and the two games he played for us.
There were a few things I noticed:
1. His footwork has improved tremendously.
With 4 PS games and 10 more weeks of practicing before he sees the field in a real game, basically, Yates has been through another season (of college ball).
The coaches did a great job with him.
As late as the Music City Bowl (his last collegiate game), Yates' footwork was still extremely inconsistent.
There were times he backpedaled into his throw (uneccessarily; ie. not due to pressure).
There were times he failed to step into his throw (again, uneccessarily).
There were times he threw from his back foot.
Etc.
It was night and day watching the Falcons game and the Music City Bowl.
2. Similar to his footwork, Yates' throwing mechanics were inconsistent.
He made a lot of things work by just winging it at times; whatever he felt comfortable with at the time.
I've noted that sometimes he brought the ball down too low (like Schaub used to do) and ended up with a long winded throwing motion.
On other occasions, some posters comment that Yates seems to "push" the ball forward.
The basics I learned from Walsh/Montana was for the QB never to bring the tip of the ball down below the waist, and always release the ball above the shoulder.
(The QB's throwing elbow should be as near shoulder height as possible or above - except for the times he just has to make any throw he can to avoid pressure, etc.)
This is why some scouting sites suggested that Yates has a three-quarter delivery.
This has also been corrected extremely well.
I was really impressed to see his consistent delivery/release in the Falcons game on all kind of different throws/situations.
.....
It amazes me how quickly Yates had improved in the two areas (and others).
This might explain in part why his stock wasn't higher as it should have been given the areas that he did well on (decision making, playing under pressure, progression in his read, etc.)