Overall definitely pleased. The Saints and Jets are both SB contenders and we beat both teams - preseason or not you have to be happy with that result.
Quick positives - The combo of Tate and Foster. Wow. Just WOW. These two have a chance (if healthy) to be one of the very best duos of all time. And how in the world did Foster go undrafted again? I mean the moves, vision, change of direction and speed of these two is incredible. I thought Priest Holmes was the cream of the crop of UDFA RBs, but Foster is easily better. He plays like a guy drafted in the top 5, and I know it's one game but Tate looked like a top 10 pick as well. Say what you will about Smithiak, but these two guys are grand slam picks. Still have to be concerned about Tate's durability though.
Schaub was spot on. What a difference having AJ and Foster makes. He was really, really good. Same can be said of AJ minus the one drop.
The 1st team oline was fantastic. A+ to all 5 guys. Granted, NO was very vanilla and we will see the crapola hit the blitz fan in game 3 but still - very good game as a group.
So far at least, the D reminds me a LOT of the 2009 Saints. They will give up some big plays, and more yardage then we will like on the ground...BUT, they will also create some of their own big plays, create many more TOs, sacks, etc. I wouldn't call it a bend but don't break - I would call it a big play defense - sometimes those plays will be our guys, and sometimes those plays will be the other guys. Still, this is a huge improvement.
All I've heard out of camp is Brooks Reed is not doing well. Well, if that's the case I hope he stinks every practice. For the second week in a row, the guy has flashed several times. He is going to wreak havoc for sure.
The not so good -
Ok Leinert is better than DanO. That's damning with faint praise. That's like saying Jimmy Carter is better than Obama. Matt L is Jimmy Carter right now. I was willing to give him a pass last week, but this is twice in a row that he has stunk. All I hear from camp is how good he looks. Yuck. He needs to pick it up in the next two.
OB27 - What's all the excitement about? He's JAG. I would be tempted to keep Slaton and go with 4 because Tate worries me health-wise. That would give us the most talented crop of RBs in the NFL imo, with very good depth. OB27 to the practice squad.
Other than the bat down, didn't see much out of Watt. Mario needs to play with his hand down. All they are doing is dragging out the inevitable. I notice that on pass plays, Reed was playing with his hand down. Why can't Mario do the same. Why do they insist on fitting a round peg into a square hole?
Last big Negative - ST. Joe M. Love the guy personally, but if he doesn't get these guys to play better and soon - he needs to hit the bricks. Both returns and coverage units are terrible. And I would keep the kid punter over the old man as well.
That about covers the high points. All in all, I was thrilled for a Preseason game, but they have much more work to do.