but, some of your statements are misconstrued.
First let me say, I'm not going to go back and redo every draft, cuz who cares and I would've drafted CARR, AJ and D-ROB cuz those positions are arguably the hardest three positions to find playmakers at.
HOWEVER, I'd like to defend some of the decent lineman that you've wrongly assessed.
LEVI JONES - is on track to be one of the elite left tackles in the league. He's better than any LT we've had on our line. How come you didn't say that?
KENDALL SIMMONS - they discovered that he had diabetes right before training camp in 2003.
Here's a quote from steelers.com,
"Simmons, the recipient of the 2002 Joe Greene Great Performance Award as the Steelers' Rookie Of The Year, was diagnosed with hyperglycemia, a diabetic condition that caused him to lose 30 pounds and significant strength right before training camp in 2003. Kendall started 14 of 16 games during his rookie season and helped the Steelers on their way to the AFC Championship game. He previously majored in Visual Communication / Graphic Arts at Auburn University where he was selected as a first team All-American by the NFL Draft Report. Although a season ending injury in the preseason washed out Kendall's 2004 campaign, he remains active in the community while undergoing rehab and looks forward to returning to All Pro form in 2005."
the link -
http://secure2.steelers.com/article/48260/
How come you didn't tell us that?
if I were to believe what you wrote, then I'd think that he just sucks?
MIKE PEARSON - Has had some knee injuries, so that somehow makes his talent level lower than Seth Wand ?
JORDAN GROSS - Played decent on the left side of the line, the coaches moved him back to the right side, cuz they weren't dominating their preferred side of the line to run the ball. It was more a reflection on them wanting to get the right side of the line back to what it was when Gross was playing there, then compared to him not being able to handle LT. He played pretty good for a young guy playing LT for the first time in the NFL. How come you didn't tell us that?
ROBERT GALLERY - Well, he's going to be a great lineman, better than anything we've got, so why even try to knock him? Give me a break.
SHAWN ANDREWS - He was already dominating his opponents when he got injured last year. Once again how do you rate a young guy low, when he's already pancaking guys with ease, in the games before he got hurt. How come you didn't tell us that ?
I could keep going, but, I fear that it is only a waste of time, since you think our line is as good as it can be.
AND since you all want to know what should've been done differently.........I'll tell ya.
Trade down into the 20ish spots........pick up more 3rd-4th picks in the drop.........and draft Chris Spencer with whatever 20ish pick we got. Lets say that we traded with Baltimore. Our 16th and 2006 5th rounder for the 22nd pick, and 5th pick (158), and 2006 4th rounder. I'm sure we could've gotten a 4th this year from someone in a trade down, but, I'll make it a more than believable trade.
So here's who I would've picked.
22nd - C - Chris Spencer - regarded as the top lineman in this years draft, one of select few in the O-line draft class that can make immediate start.
73rd - RB - Vernand Morency - I might've gone after DT Attiyah Ellison, since he could be a great fit on our line, with his speed and size......but, I can't knock the Morency pick, since he was the 4th rated back on some teams lists. I'll try to listen to my advisors as much as possible.
114 - WR - Jerome "FLASH" Mathis - This guy is TURBO and in a couple years we could have the fastest starting WR tandem in the league. Definitely a great pick, since all young recievers need work on their route-running anyways. You can't teach speed. We've got enough depth in our receiving corps to give him the proper time to develop. But, like every other FAN I hope they try to get him the ball this year too.
151 - S - Gerald Sensabaugh - This guy is great value in the 5th round. I think he'll be a good starter in this league. I personally think the Defensive line needs a ton of help so I would've lobbied for DT Anthony Bryant, but, they seemed to want a safety as well.
158 - DT - Anttaj Hawthorne - This guy can play anywhere on the line in the 3-4 with his great size and athletic ability. He'll be a starter.
188 - TE - Adam Bergen - One of the few tight ends in the draft that was a decent receiver as well as blocker. He went undrafted but, the Cardinals snatched him up fast as an UDFA
227 - OLB - Derek Wake - He's a great athlete and many scouts said he was probably best suited for 3-4 defense. Capers wants a linebacker, and this guy is already known as a great blitzer and good at covering TEs. The Giants signed him to an UDFA contract. I also might've taken a look at SS Kurt Campbell who at 6-1 233 runs the 40 in 4.47. Had I taken Bryant over Sensabaugh in the 5th round.