I'd prefer that we trade down for an extra pick & pick up Matt Roth.
Roth has a non-stop motor, a mean streak a mile wide, is faster & quicker than Spears, & will require less polishing than Spears. Roth doesn't
"shut down his motor when his initial move fails in his attempts to disengage from the blocker" (that's a direct quote about Spears from NFL.com's player profiles). Also, Roth has played with this kind of intensity throughout his college career.
Spears may have all the talent in the world, but I have a problem with players/people that don't give their all, at whatever they're doing, all the time. Spears has been inconsistent throughout his college career. At least, until the 2nd half of last year. Maybe, he's finally gotten it, but I tend to think that his future agent, or someone close to him, convinced him to turn up his game in order to improve his draft position.
Roth has played with such a high intensity every time he stepped on the field, that the coaches had to hold him back in practices, for fear that he'd hurt one of his own offensive players. He's got a mean streak that the Texan's could use on the line & he plays like he's on a "Search & Destroy" mission. I really like this kid.
I love this write up on Roth from DraftDaddy.com.
MATT ROTH
In terms of demeanor on the football field, Matt Roth is one of our favorite players in this entire draft. He compares with former Cowboy Randy White {a.k.a the Manster}. Although their positions differ {White was a DT}, both men possessed that raw God-Given Power which differs from weight-room strength. Roth, like Manster, looks like he's been chopping down redwoods since he was six years old he has that same type of rawbone/lumberjack power. That's not to say he's one dimentional, as he's pretty darn quick to boot, with outstanding pass rush handplay. And best of all this guy's meaner than a rattle-snake. He's got that Butkus mentality ... as Paul Hourning once said, he plays football like he HATES YOU.
We watched Roth versus some of the best senior OT's in the nation at the Senior Bowl and he made them look completely over-matched ... ALL DAY ... had them playing on roller-skates. It's become a cliche but Roth truly has a non-stop motor to match his low center of gravity and great upfield burst. There was a story out of 2002 Iowa spring practice that Roth once got so fired up during drills that after another player pulled his facemask, Roth responded by ripping off the facemask entirely off the opposing player's helmet- the story gets better when it's revealed that the "other player" was man-mountain #2 overall selection Robert Gallery.
It's been a long time since we've seen a DE overwhelm bigger OT's with such force and a desire to make the play. Come to think of it, Matt Roth also reminds us of former NY Jet All-Pro defensive end, Joe Klecko. That might be an even better comparison than Manster, since neither man was blessed with prototypical measurements for their position, but both have the heart to be counted among the best in the league. Although most boards have many players higher than Roth at the DE position, we are convinced that Matt Roth is going to be a force in the NFL, and wherever he is selected it will be a steal.