Be Honest What is your pick - Houston Texans Message Board & Forum

Joe Texan · 06-29-2004

Just saw this on the Teetons Board and was curious

Which QB will be getting a SB ring first

Carr.............My Vote, Coming in the next 3 years
McNair..........Curse of Bud
LeftWhich.....Here Kitty Kitty Kitty
P. Manning.......Whats the matter Daddy don't love you?

Couldn't do a poll so just post your answer with an explanation.

Grid · 06-29-2004

I dunno.. Carr or Manning. McNair.. he isnt gonna last through the Titans next rebuilding stage. Leftwhich.. Jags are good but I think we are gonna be better.

I think Manning is a possibility.. but of course im gonna say Carr

done88 · 06-29-2004

CARR If I thought it was going to be someone else what kinda fan(atic) would I be. Now this may be another story come playoff time. But until the Texans are out of the playoffs I think Carr has as good a chance as any.

**edo783** · 06-29-2004

Obviously my heart is with David. However, Manning has the best chance to make it first, but if the Colts don't make it this year, then I see it as being up for grabs by us and the Jags and I think we will be on top.

**beerlover** · 06-29-2004

MANNING

McNAIR

CARR

LEFTWICH

**SheTexan** · 06-29-2004

Manning

Carr

McNair

Puss in boots! :hehe:

**Chance_C** · 06-29-2004

It's a difficult year to answer that question. I think that Manning has the best chance to do it within the next year or two. But if it doesn't happen pretty quick, it will become Carr then Leftwich. As Grid stated, I don't think that McNair will make it through the Titans next rebuilding stage. I think his best oppurtunity has passed him by...

**TEXANS84** · 06-29-2004

McNair
Carr
Manning
Leftwich

cuppacoffee · 06-29-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by TEXAN84

McNair
Carr
Manning
Leftwich

If McNair gets traded to another team, maybe, who knows?
Trade McNair? Trust me .....now that the Budster is back in charge anything can/will happen. It's all about the $$$$$

SBTexans08 · 06-29-2004

I say Chance C is 100% correct. I'll go with his take on it...

TheOgre · 06-29-2004

I think the window of opportunity for McNair is dwindling in a year or two:

Manning
Leftwich
Carr
McNair

WWJD · 06-29-2004

Manning. Only 1 game away last year.

Fiddy · 06-29-2004

Manning, but I think this year is his last chance for awhile because the defense is already poor and with his $100 million contract the Colts will lose either James or Harrison after this coming season.

Panther5407 · 06-29-2004

CARR, the Texans lost around 8-9 games in close ones, including the Superbowl champs, with tons upon tons of injuries. I would say the Colts but their O cant do everything. The titans lost too many keys on d and the jags just arnt there yet.

Nawzer · 06-29-2004

Manning
Carr
Leftwich
McNair

TheOgre · 06-29-2004

Harrison is going to stay with the Colts. E James will go because he has lost a step since his injury.

Tulip · 06-29-2004

Peyton Manning

done88 · 06-30-2004

Carr
Carr
Manning
Carr
Lefty
Manning
Carr
Carr

In no particular order

Scooter · 06-30-2004

you should take out "honest" ... honestly any texans fan is going to take carr, realistically any football fan is going to take manning if we're staying strictly on qb's.

manning
mcnair
carr
leftwich

first to the superbowl is different, the titans are the most complete.

mcnair
carr (ok, i'm a lil bias)
leftwich
manning

J-Man · 06-30-2004

Manning...if he can remove the chicken bone thats been choking him in big playoff games!

Carr/Leftwich...toss up, a lot will depend on how their teams develop around them.

McNair...his team looks to be ready to take the big slide into .500 ball or worse for the next couple years. There are probably 2 good seasons left but talent is starting to get thin in Nashville this year.

06-29-2004	#1
Joe Texan Inducted 04 Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: Spring Section: 116 row a seat 20 Age: 50 Posts: 9,784 Rep Power: 4089	Be Honest What is your pick Just saw this on the Teetons Board and was curious Which QB will be getting a SB ring first Carr.............My Vote, Coming in the next 3 years McNair..........Curse of Bud LeftWhich.....Here Kitty Kitty Kitty P. Manning.......Whats the matter Daddy don't love you? Couldn't do a poll so just post your answer with an explanation. __________________ PRAYERS TO THE FALLEN AT FT. HOOD

06-29-2004	#3
done88 Veteran Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Clear Lake Age: 35 Posts: 274 Rep Power: 10	CARR If I thought it was going to be someone else what kinda fan(atic) would I be. Now this may be another story come playoff time. But until the Texans are out of the playoffs I think Carr has as good a chance as any. __________________ Donnie I've adopted Eric Moulds

06-29-2004	#4
edo783 Site Contributor Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Houston, again. Posts: 7,700 Rep Power: 4640	Obviously my heart is with David. However, Manning has the best chance to make it first, but if the Colts don't make it this year, then I see it as being up for grabs by us and the Jags and I think we will be on top. __________________ De Oppresso Liber

06-29-2004	#5
beerlover Site Contributor Join Date: May 2004 Posts: 11,358 Rep Power: 15075	which qb will get a sb ring first? MANNING McNAIR CARR LEFTWICH

06-29-2004	#7
Chance_C Site Contributor Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Livingston Texas Age: 42 Posts: 1,463 Rep Power: 2039	It's a difficult year to answer that question. I think that Manning has the best chance to do it within the next year or two. But if it doesn't happen pretty quick, it will become Carr then Leftwich. As Grid stated, I don't think that McNair will make it through the Titans next rebuilding stage. I think his best oppurtunity has passed him by... __________________ I'm a hell bent 100% Texan till I die...

06-29-2004	#2
Grid Hall of Fame Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 4,299 Rep Power: 2271	I dunno.. Carr or Manning. McNair.. he isnt gonna last through the Titans next rebuilding stage. Leftwhich.. Jags are good but I think we are gonna be better. I think Manning is a possibility.. but of course im gonna say Carr

06-29-2004	#8
TEXANS84 Moderator Join Date: May 2004 Location: The Woodlands, TX Age: 35 Posts: 7,447 Rep Power: 3116	McNair Carr Manning Leftwich

06-29-2004	#10
SBTexans08 All Pro Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: 3rd Coast Age: 33 Posts: 677 Rep Power: 10	I say Chance C is 100% correct. I'll go with his take on it... __________________ MY XBOX 360 GAMER PROFILE

06-29-2004	#11
TheOgre Hall of Fame Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Back in the cellar again Posts: 3,739 Rep Power: 16	I think the window of opportunity for McNair is dwindling in a year or two: Manning Leftwich Carr McNair

06-29-2004	#12
WWJD Hall of Fame Join Date: May 2004 Posts: 5,260 Rep Power: 374	Manning. Only 1 game away last year.

06-29-2004	#13
Fiddy Hall of Fame Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Houston/Austin Age: 25 Posts: 4,314 Rep Power: 17	Manning, but I think this year is his last chance for awhile because the defense is already poor and with his $100 million contract the Colts will lose either James or Harrison after this coming season. __________________ 'Anyone ready to go outside so I can make you look bad?' - Matt Schaub talking to the DBs

06-29-2004	#14
Panther5407 All Pro Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Houston, Texas Age: 23 Posts: 816 Rep Power: 9	CARR, the Texans lost around 8-9 games in close ones, including the Superbowl champs, with tons upon tons of injuries. I would say the Colts but their O cant do everything. The titans lost too many keys on d and the jags just arnt there yet. __________________ Texan By Birth, Aggie by the Grace of God

06-29-2004	#15
Nawzer Alienz Join Date: May 2004 Location: Houston, TX Age: 30 Posts: 6,085 Rep Power: 14368	Manning Carr Leftwich McNair __________________ Fortune favors the brave NOT the stupid!

06-29-2004	#17
Tulip Hall of Fame Join Date: Jun 2004 Age: 37 Posts: 1,864 Rep Power: 13	Peyton Manning

06-30-2004	#18
done88 Veteran Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Clear Lake Age: 35 Posts: 274 Rep Power: 10	Carr Carr Manning Carr Lefty Manning Carr Carr In no particular order __________________ Donnie I've adopted Eric Moulds

Remove advertisements Sponsored links

06-30-2004	#19
Scooter Funky Join Date: Apr 2004 Age: 33 Posts: 4,210 Rep Power: 11587	you should take out "honest" ... honestly any texans fan is going to take carr, realistically any football fan is going to take manning if we're staying strictly on qb's. manning mcnair carr leftwich first to the superbowl is different, the titans are the most complete. mcnair carr (ok, i'm a lil bias) leftwich manning __________________

06-30-2004	#20
J-Man Veteran Join Date: May 2004 Location: Ft Hood, Tx Age: 37 Posts: 402 Rep Power: 10	Manning...if he can remove the chicken bone thats been choking him in big playoff games! Carr/Leftwich...toss up, a lot will depend on how their teams develop around them. McNair...his team looks to be ready to take the big slide into .500 ball or worse for the next couple years. There are probably 2 good seasons left but talent is starting to get thin in Nashville this year. __________________ Who's the Man?... J-Man, that's WHO! Eat 'em Up, KATS!

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode