What if Andre Said......

[thunderkyss]

What if Andre Said he won't play for another coach? What if Andre told the Texans he would demand a trade if they dumped Kubiak?

What if that's the only reason Kubiak is still here?

[eriadoc]

What if a frog had wings?

He wouldn't bump his ass when he jumped.

[STEEL BLUE TEXANS]

I would immediately have Andre tested for illegal drugs.

[CloakNNNdagger]

Originally Posted by thunderkyss

What if Andre Said he won't play for another coach? What if Andre told the Texans he would demand a trade if they dumped Kubiak?

What if that's the only reason Kubiak is still here?

That type decision tree would be an even sadder state of affairs than what I am now envisioning.

[HTown2ATX]

Originally Posted by CloakNNNdagger

That type decision tree would be an even sadder state of affairs than what I am now envisioning.

Correct.

Also, I think Andre likes winning.

Somthing that so far has not been brought by

Nor will it be brought by and IMO but hope I am wrong.

[Lucky]

Originally Posted by thunderkyss

What if Andre Said he won't play for another coach?

He wouldn't say that. This guy played for Joe Pendry and with David Carr, and never said a peep. What I am worried about is wasting another year of this future HOFers career. I'm also worried about him asking for a trade, if the Texans lose again next year. You can see on his face his disgust with the situation.

There's no positive spin from McNair's incompetent decision to keep Kubiak. It's bad enough that we are getting dumped on by the owner. Please, no more bogus spin.

[Yesterday]

Andre would never say that, dumb thread.

[thunderkyss]

Originally Posted by Yesterday

Andre would never say that, dumb thread.

dumb reply, yours & everyone else who has trouble reading. I didn't ask if Andre would say it, I said what if he did.

it's an attempt to get the conversation going in a different direction around here.

[gary]

Johnson would not say that I just don't think he is a very public person.

[Pantherstang84]

Originally Posted by thunderkyss

dumb reply, yours & everyone else who has trouble reading. I didn't ask if Andre would say it, I said what if he did.

it's an attempt to get the conversation going in a different direction around here.

What if my Aunt had balls?

[BetaV1]

Lovely. TK proposes a pretty thought-provoking hypothetical to generate discussion and rather than answer said hypothetical, people just duck the question altogether.

TK must just be another hired goon for the McNair PR machine.

[Thorn]

If a cat could bark, would it chase cats?

If a snake could talk, would it be offering apples?

[Thorn]

Originally Posted by thunderkyss

What if Andre Said he won't play for another coach? What if Andre told the Texans he would demand a trade if they dumped Kubiak?

What if that's the only reason Kubiak is still here?

Well, to be serious about your question, AJ wouldn't do this. But if he did, I don't think it would change anyone's mind. McNair is gonna do what he's gonna do.

[Doppelganger]

Originally Posted by thunderkyss

What if Andre Said he won't play for another coach? What if Andre told the Texans he would demand a trade if they dumped Kubiak?

What if that's the only reason Kubiak is still here?

I would immediately trade him for a couple of first rounders. Players do not dictate who the coach is. If you allow one player to do so, other, lesser players will do that and undermine the coach's power.

As much as I like AJ, no one person is above the team.

[Rey]

I don't understand what kind of conversation this is supposed to generate other than the replies that have already been given.

[Lucky]

Originally Posted by thunderkyss

dumb reply, yours & everyone else who has trouble reading.

Sorry, but this thread has received the respect it deserves. What if Napoleon had B-1 bombers at Waterloo?

Get real.

[thunderkyss]

Originally Posted by CloakNNNdagger

That type decision tree would be an even sadder state of affairs than what I am now envisioning.

Thank you for at least responding to the question asked. I agree... then we'd really know how screwed up this organization is.

[thunderkyss]

Originally Posted by Doppelganger1

I would immediately trade him for a couple of first rounders. Players do not dictate who the coach is. If you allow one player to do so, other, lesser players will do that and undermine the coach's power.

As much as I like AJ, no one person is above the team.

I hear what you're saying. But the premise here (sorry if I did not explicitly state it)..... is that it's a done deal, what if it is going down this way, because Andre says so.

I agree with you, & it appears most people in this thread (even though they hadn't said as much) would believe it's a pretty screwed up deal, a player deciding if it's time for coach K to go..... almost as bad as a coach hirign a GM.

So let's throw that question out. What do you think, if McNair's only reason for keeping Kubiak, is because the players like him?

[CretorFrigg]

Why do I get the feeling this thread was made solely to rile us up?

[Rey]

Originally Posted by thunderkyss

So let's throw that question out. What do you think, if McNair's only reason for keeping Kubiak, is because the players like him?

I just can't believe that McNair would run his franchise like that...

That's the kind of decision an insecure twelve year old makes...