Garcon or Crabtree - Houston Texans Message Board & Forum

V Man · 09-09-2010

Need a second receiver.

Pierre Garcon vs Texans

or

Michael Crabtree vs Seahawks

Unfortunately I am thinking Garcon is the better choice. What do you think?

**Hardcore Texan** · 09-09-2010

Tough call, especially because of the Manning factor, and they should both start. I think our pass D will be better than the Seahawks (they were terrible last year) for one and I am already leaning toward Crabtree anyway (especially if it's a PPR league). So get some Crabs, IMO.

**Dutchrudder** · 09-09-2010

I'm starting Crabtree in one of my leagues. Not over Garcon, but I just know the 49ers will tear up the Seahawks and Crabtree is a prime target.

thunderkyss · 09-09-2010

I'm starting the Texans defense in my league.

Garcon won't be having a good day Sept. 12th.

Blake · 09-09-2010

Crabtree. He is a top 2 option in SF. Garcon is 3rd at best.

**HOU-TEX** · 09-09-2010

I think they'll both do ok, but I'd probably give Crabtree the nod vs the Hawks

**Hardcore Texan** · 09-09-2010

Quote:

Originally Posted by Super Mario

Crabtree. He is a top 2 option in SF. Garcon is 3rd at best.

Crabtree is #1 on the DC, Garcon is #2. So I am guessing they'll both get the start and plenty of reps.

09-09-2010

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hardcore Texan

Crabtree is #1 on the DC, Garcon is #2. So I am guessing they'll both get the start and plenty of reps.

He means overall receiving targets. For Peyton, it is Wayne, Clark, and then Garcon. For Smith, it is Crabtree and Vernon Davis as 1A and 1B.

V Man · 09-10-2010

Thanks for the advice. Probably goning with Crabtree.

(but with my luck, no matter who I start, the other one is having a career day.

)

Mr teX · 09-10-2010

Garcon simply b/c of the manning factor. Crabtree doesn't have anyone who can get him the ball consistently.

09-09-2010	#3
Dutchrudder COOL BEANS! Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Houston Section: Fort Kickass Age: 28 Posts: 13,688 Rep Power: 77704	Re: Garcon or Crabtree I'm starting Crabtree in one of my leagues. Not over Garcon, but I just know the 49ers will tear up the Seahawks and Crabtree is a prime target. __________________

09-09-2010	#4
thunderkyss Hopkins Beyatch Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Pt Arthur Texas Age: 40 Posts: 25,704 Rep Power: 51478	Re: Garcon or Crabtree I'm starting the Texans defense in my league. Garcon won't be having a good day Sept. 12th. __________________ I swear it's for real this time!

09-09-2010	#5
Blake MMQB Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Spring Section: 551/B Posts: 9,581 Rep Power: 14926	Re: Garcon or Crabtree Crabtree. He is a top 2 option in SF. Garcon is 3rd at best. __________________

09-09-2010	#6
HOU-TEX Ah, Football! Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: P-land Age: 42 Posts: 14,143 Rep Power: 19780	Re: Garcon or Crabtree I think they'll both do ok, but I'd probably give Crabtree the nod vs the Hawks __________________ "We wanted to make a statement, run the ball and make them like it." - Duane Brown

09-10-2010	#9
V Man Pumpkinhead Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Alamo City Age: 45 Posts: 2,586 Rep Power: 18	Re: Garcon or Crabtree Thanks for the advice. Probably goning with Crabtree. (but with my luck, no matter who I start, the other one is having a career day.) __________________ sig by michaelm

09-09-2010	#1
V Man Pumpkinhead Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Alamo City Age: 45 Posts: 2,586 Rep Power: 18	Garcon or Crabtree Need a second receiver. Pierre Garcon vs Texans or Michael Crabtree vs Seahawks Unfortunately I am thinking Garcon is the better choice. What do you think? __________________ sig by michaelm

09-09-2010	#2
Hardcore Texan Magnet Man Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: Round Rock, TX Age: 38 Posts: 9,383 Rep Power: 18364	Re: Garcon or Crabtree Tough call, especially because of the Manning factor, and they should both start. I think our pass D will be better than the Seahawks (they were terrible last year) for one and I am already leaning toward Crabtree anyway (especially if it's a PPR league). So get some Crabs, IMO. __________________ Warning: This post may or may not contain sarcasm, satire, or humor in general. Read at your own risk! Would you like free electricity? TellEveryone.energy526.com

09-10-2010	#10
Mr teX Hall of Fame Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Everyone Wants The Throne Posts: 6,262 Rep Power: 11378	Re: Garcon or Crabtree Garcon simply b/c of the manning factor. Crabtree doesn't have anyone who can get him the ball consistently.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Remove advertisements Sponsored links