Weekly Sit/Start Discussion Thread

[The1ApplePie]

For my RB/WR position, I'm torn between Maclin and Mark Clayton (Rams).

I already have DeSean Jackson and I don't think Vick will throw enough for both. Plus, Bradford and Clayton have a chemistry.

[Line_Producer]

Originally Posted by The1ApplePie

For my RB/WR position, I'm torn between Maclin and Mark Clayton (Rams).

I already have DeSean Jackson and I don't think Vick will throw enough for both. Plus, Bradford and Clayton have a chemistry.

I personally wouldn't start both receivers from the same team. There's nothing worse than getting shut out by the run game.

I'd go Clayton if he's your only other option, even better if you're playing PPR.

-wil

[HOU-TEX]

Got a minor dilemma here.

Would y'all start Cutler against the Packers? Or Vick against the Jags?

I'm leaning towards Vick, but need that 2nd opinion.

[Goldensilence]

Do I start Miami Defense against Jets or Washington defense vs rams?

Leaning towards DC.

[JB]

Originally Posted by HOU-TEX

Got a minor dilemma here.

Would y'all start Cutler against the Packers? Or Vick against the Jags?

I'm leaning towards Vick, but need that 2nd opinion.

I would probably go Vick, 'cause I think Cutler is going to be under pressure all game.
But iirc, Cutler did handle the 'gurls pressure pretty well.

[HOU-TEX]

Originally Posted by JB

I would probably go Vick, 'cause I think Cutler is going to be under pressure all game.
But iirc, Cutler did handle the 'gurls pressure pretty well.

LOL, gee JB, that really helps a lot. That's basically what I've been thinking already.

[JB]

Originally Posted by HOU-TEX

LOL, gee JB, that really helps a lot. That's basically what I've been thinking already.

You said you wanted an opinion. You didn't say I had to disagree with you...lol

[dc_txtech]

Originally Posted by The1ApplePie

For my RB/WR position, I'm torn between Maclin and Mark Clayton (Rams).

I already have DeSean Jackson and I don't think Vick will throw enough for both. Plus, Bradford and Clayton have a chemistry.

Pretty risky to start 2 WR's from the same team, I'd go Clayton.

Originally Posted by HOU-TEX

Got a minor dilemma here.

Would y'all start Cutler against the Packers? Or Vick against the Jags?

I'm leaning towards Vick, but need that 2nd opinion.

That's a tough one, I'm also leaning towards Vick. Cutler is risky against that GB defense.

Originally Posted by Goldensilence

Do I start Miami Defense against Jets or Washington defense vs rams?

Leaning towards DC.

I'd go Miami, jmo.

[Line_Producer]

Originally Posted by HOU-TEX

Got a minor dilemma here.

Would y'all start Cutler against the Packers? Or Vick against the Jags?

I'm in the same boat and I chose to go with Cutler. LOL I have GB defense too. I'm a firm believer that any qb in a Martz system will get the points. I think Vick is a close second, especially against the Jags.

[mattieuk]

Alright...got a relative FUBAR situation going on at QB.

I've got Favre, McNabb and Derek Anderson.

I've gone Favre last two weeks...thinking that its time to pull the trigger and go McNabb after last weeks game.

[Line_Producer]

Originally Posted by mattieuk

Alright...got a relative FUBAR situation going on at QB.

I've got Favre, McNabb and Derek Anderson.

I've gone Favre last two weeks...thinking that its time to pull the trigger and go McNabb after last weeks game.

Well, Anderson is def out.
I've practically given up on Favre too, but he's playing DET who's given up the 2nd most? points to opposing qbs. If Favre can't get it done this week, bench him.

[mattieuk]

Originally Posted by Line_Producer

Well, Anderson is def out.
I've practically given up on Favre too, but he's playing DET who's given up the 2nd most? points to opposing qbs. If Favre can't get it done this week, bench him.

I know, thats the only pull for Favre, but after his performance last week, well I'm almost done with him. I was pretty stoked at my QB corps going into the week, now I'm pretty much down on them both Brett and Derek Anderson. I'll leave Favre starting then, and only change if I get a last minute impulse he's going to blow it. Less than 10 points again, and thats it, he's benched, and I'm not buying Wrangler ever.

[BigBull17]

Kyle Orton vs Colts or Matt Ryan vs N.O?

[Blake]

Originally Posted by HOU-TEX

Got a minor dilemma here.

Would y'all start Cutler against the Packers? Or Vick against the Jags?

I'm leaning towards Vick, but need that 2nd opinion.

Cutler against the Pack.

Vick is a good QB when you prepare for Kolb. Or when you are playing the Lions. He will be on the road.

Cutler is an actual QB. Playing at home. Vs. a good defense.

I think its 6 one way, 1/2 dozen the other. But I will go with Cutler.

[Goldensilence]

Originally Posted by HOU-TEX

Got a minor dilemma here.

Would y'all start Cutler against the Packers? Or Vick against the Jags?

I'm leaning towards Vick, but need that 2nd opinion.

I'd go with Vick against the Jags. Not like they have a lock down secondary.

I'm also having a tough time at TE.

Just picked up Jermaine Gresham on the wire, I Really like OD as my starter but his lack of production is costing me at the moment. Should I go after Dustin Keller?

[Blake]

Originally Posted by Goldensilence

I'd go with Vick against the Jags. Not like they have a lock down secondary.

I'm also having a tough time at TE.

Just picked up Jermaine Gresham on the wire, I Really like OD as my starter but his lack of production is costing me at the moment. Should I go after Dustin Keller?

Gresham or Keller. I would go Gresham.

[Goldensilence]

Originally Posted by dc_txtech

Pretty risky to start 2 WR's from the same team, I'd go Clayton.



That's a tough one, I'm also leaning towards Vick. Cutler is risky against that GB defense.



I'd go Miami, jmo.

My deal is this... I know Sanchez has struggled and the Miami d looked pretty darn good against Favre in Minn.

But, I like the matchup with DC having St. Louis.

I'm torn.

[Blake]

Ronnie Brown vs. NYJ or Marion Barber @ Texans.

Brown is projected to get 12, while Barber is projected to get 6.

But as a Texans fan I dont see how you think we will keep the cowboys out of the endzone. Yes, Barber is a RBBC, but so is Brown to a degree, plus Brown is going up against a stout front Dline.

Leaning towards Barber. Any suggestions?

[dc_txtech]

Originally Posted by Super Mario

Ronnie Brown vs. NYJ or Marion Barber @ Texans.

Brown is projected to get 12, while Barber is projected to get 6.

But as a Texans fan I dont see how you think we will keep the cowboys out of the endzone. Yes, Barber is a RBBC, but so is Brown to a degree, plus Brown is going up against a stout front Dline.

Leaning towards Barber. Any suggestions?

Ouch, any other options?

[Blake]

Originally Posted by dc_txtech

Ouch, any other options?

This is my flex spot. I am already starting AP and Brandon Jackson.

Ronnie Brown vs. NYJ

Marion Barber @ HOU

Chester Taylor vs. GB