Death to Google Ads! Texans Talk Tip Jar! 🍺😎👍
Thanks for your support!

Johnson listed as 7th most irreplaceable player in NFL

G

gtexan02

Working?
From ESPN Insider:
http://insider.espn.go.com/nfl/insider/news/story?id=4269904

Anyone who still thinks A Davis was just as good as AJ should read this:

7. Andre Johnson, WR, Texans

We could just list the wide receivers whom Johnson has spent his career playing across from, but that doesn't quantify just how important Johnson's presence is to making the Texans' offense work. Instead, we'll look back to 2007, when Johnson was on the shelf for seven games. Their passing DVOA was 11th in the league with Johnson in the lineup and 19th without, but he had an even bigger impact on the running game; the Texans actually had the fifth-best rushing DVOA in football when Johnson was around, falling to 28th when he was injured. Think he keeps a safety or two occupied?
Click to expand...
Am I allowed to post this?
 
eriadoc

eriadoc

Texan-American
I think he should be higher than 7th. IMO, only Manning and Brady are more irreplaceable.

If those really are your new plates, I am very disappointed. You should have used these plates:

 
Texecutioner

Texecutioner

Hall of Fame
I don't think 7th is bad at all. I mean there are so many positions where there are great irreplaceable players on each team.

Troy Polumolu and Ed Reed are irreplaceable no question as safeties.

Mario and Jared Allen are irreplaceable as DE's.

Brady, Brees, and Manning are irreplaceable as QB's.

There are several irreplaceable O lineman.

This is hard to rank.
 
nero THE zero

nero THE zero

All Pro
gtexan02 said:
If you followed the board back then, there were quite a few. I can recall at least a few from the "All your eggs in one basket" thread as well

For example
Click to expand...
I've followed the board since before Andre Davis was ever here. I don't recall anyone ever saying AD is as good as AJ. Saying that he did a fine job in AJ's stead is not the same as saying he is as good as AJ. That's not to say some troll didn't make a silly statement like that. We've seen that. But, to act like that was some sort of prevelent idea is inaccruate.
 
G

gtexan02

Working?
nero THE zero said:
I've followed the board since before Andre Davis was ever here. I don't recall anyone ever saying AD is as good as AJ. Saying that he did a fine job in AJ's stead is not the same as saying he is as good as AJ. That's not to say some troll didn't make a silly statement like that. We've seen that. But, to act like that was some sort of prevelent idea is inaccruate.
Click to expand...
Not sure why you are taking this quite so literally. I dont think anyone would ever say that the two are exactly equal--thats crazy. I was implying that I remember, and still see, some posts doubting AJ's irreplaceability because of Andre Davis' performance in during the 2007 season. Thats what this thread is about
 
G

gtexan02

Working?
texasguy346 said:
I believe gtexan lives in Virginia or somewhere in that area. Might be hard to find one of those plates up there. :cowboy1:
Click to expand...
I do indeed! Maybe I should have included that in the photo...ok, changed it

Something sad happened to me only a short while after I got the plates.... someone actually asked me what the "Toxins" were. :(

We need more national media coverage...
 
badboy

badboy

Hall of Fame
gtexan02 said:
If you followed the board back then, there were quite a few. I can recall at least a few from the "All your eggs in one basket" thread as well

For example
Click to expand...
gtexan need to improve your reading skills. The quote of mine said he did a fine job and he did. Never said he was AJ equal. The entire point of my thread was which one player could not be replaced and the team be successful. My choice was QB Matt Schaub. If AJ goes out this year, Aj has a decent replacement. Productivity not the same but does not immediately regulate team to "uh oh" status. Schaub goes out for season and we have a 2nd stringer with little more than potential (though I like him) and Rex Grossman that no other team wanted. Again, I never said AD= AJ.
 
I

Insideop

All Pro
badboy said:
gtexan need to improve your reading skills. The quote of mine said he did a fine job and he did. Never said he was AJ equal. The entire point of my thread was which one player could not be replaced and the team be successful. My choice was QB Matt Schaub. If AJ goes out this year, Aj has a decent replacement. Productivity not the same but does not immediately regulate team to "uh oh" status. Schaub goes out for season and we have a 2nd stringer with little more than potential (though I like him) and Rex Grossman that no other team wanted. Again, I never said AD= AJ.
Click to expand...
:popcorn: Keep it going boys! It's a long off season with nothing left to do but :pirate: and :deadhorse! :D
 
G

gtexan02

Working?
badboy said:
gtexan need to improve your reading skills. The quote of mine said he did a fine job and he did. Never said he was AJ equal. The entire point of my thread was which one player could not be replaced and the team be successful. My choice was QB Matt Schaub. If AJ goes out this year, Aj has a decent replacement. Productivity not the same but does not immediately regulate team to "uh oh" status. Schaub goes out for season and we have a 2nd stringer with little more than potential (though I like him) and Rex Grossman that no other team wanted. Again, I never said AD= AJ.
Click to expand...
Before flinging around insults to others reading skills, maybe you should check yours. I said just a few posts (5) above yours:

Not sure why you are taking this quite so literally. I dont think anyone would ever say that the two are exactly equal--thats crazy. I was implying that I remember, and still see, some posts doubting AJ's irreplaceability because of Andre Davis' performance in during the 2007 season. Thats what this thread is about
Click to expand...
 
Texans_Chick

Texans_Chick

Utopian Dreamer
I would never ever want something to happen to AJ.

That being said, the Texans of 2007 are likely a little different than the Texans of today. Because of:

Another year for Schaub and rest of offense
Steve Slaton
Alex Gibbs

I hope to never have to find out how irreplaceable AJ is.
 
P

Polo

Guest
I think that because of the offensive scheme we run we can get by with back up players in some spots more easily than other teams can.

I think all this irreplaceable stuff is just for arguments sake. AJ is a beast. I'll wait to quantify how much of a beast he til he retires.
 
Yankee_In_TX

Yankee_In_TX

Dance Lindsay!
gtexan02 said:
If you followed the board back then, there were quite a few. I can recall at least a few from the "All your eggs in one basket" thread as well

For example
Click to expand...
*me*

I said we had so many friggin' problems that we were putting WAY too much on AJ being back on the field changing the way the defense plays. I said he's our best player, but 1 guy CANNOT make that much difference.

I admittedly eat crow every time that topic comes up.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top