Chomp Chomp Chomp - Houston Texans Message Board & Forum

Joe Texan · 08-18-2008

Yep thats me chomping on the crow over Sage being better than Matt. If we get the production from Matt for the remainder of theis season like we got saturday night then he hands down deserves the starting job. I know I was all in Sages corner but Matt just took it to the bank and deposited a gem.
So if all you I told you so's need to pile on me as I enjoy the crow feathers and all, then here ya go, let me have it.

Sideline · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Texan

If we get the production from Matt for the remainder of theis season like we got saturday night then he hands down deserves the starting job.

If we get production from Matt this season like we did Saturday then he will be deserving a Pro Bowl to go along with his starting job....Sorry may be getting a little ahead of myself there. lol.

**gtexan02** · 08-18-2008

I think Matt is better than Sage. But lets not forget the Saints had the 32 ranked pass defense last season

Texan Asylum · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Texan

Yep thats me chomping on the crow over Sage being better than Matt. If we get the production from Matt for the remainder of theis season like we got saturday night then he hands down deserves the starting job. I know I was all in Sages corner but Matt just took it to the bank and deposited a gem.
So if all you I told you so's need to pile on me as I enjoy the crow feathers and all, then here ya go, let me have it.

I believe we ALL have had to eat crow at some point in time rooting for the Texans.

thunderkyss · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Watchman

I believe we ALL have had to eat crow at some point in time rooting for the Texans.

True dat......

I won't be able to watch the game, till I get home tonight. So I still haven't seen Matt do anything that would make him "special".

I never said Sage was better than Matt...... only that they were both good enough to get the job done. I hope Matt does separate himself in 2008.

ubecool454 · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Texan

Yep thats me chomping on the crow over Sage being better than Matt. If we get the production from Matt for the remainder of theis season like we got saturday night then he hands down deserves the starting job. I know I was all in Sages corner but Matt just took it to the bank and deposited a gem.
So if all you I told you so's need to pile on me as I enjoy the crow feathers and all, then here ya go, let me have it.

Its ok...thats why Kubiak is the coach and you are not..lol. I always liked Schaub since seeing him play at UVA. The guy is heady and laid back. He doesn't have the strongest arm but if Andre/Andre/Walter like him...then I love him.

ubecool454 · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Watchman

I believe we ALL have had to eat crow at some point in time rooting for the Texans.

NEVER! NOT ME..lol

**Tedc** · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by joe texan

so if all you i told you so's need to pile on me as i enjoy the crow feathers and all, then here ya go, let me have it.

itys!

cuppacoffee · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Watchman

I believe we ALL have had to eat crow at some point in time rooting for the Texans.

Not me!

Although I did support Da ....

aw...never mind.

Pass the salt and pepper.

Brandon420tx · 08-18-2008

Greenwood has made me eat crow a few times. He's also made me spit it back out, I wish he would make up his mind.

ubecool454 · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brandon420tx

Greenwood has made me eat crow a few times. He's also made me spit it back out, I wish he would make up his mind.

Was it me or does Greenwood look very fat and very slow now?

Texan Asylum · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by cuppacoffee

Not me!

Although I did support Da ....

aw...never mind.

Pass the salt and pepper.

Hahahahahaaaaaaaaaaa!!!

That 'name we shall not mention'...me too!

err...uhmmm, would you pass that when you're done Cup!

Mr PC · 08-18-2008

I have seen many posts similar to this, all because one preseason performance. Schaub did look good vs the Saints playing the "lets throw at Jason David" game. But now everybody is jumping on his nuts because of one preseason game? If Sage happened to look better than Matt, the first thing I would expect to hear is "its just a preseason game." Now people are talking about Matt as a top 5 QB and comparing him to Tom Brady because he had a good preseason game.

Brandon420tx · 08-18-2008

Shun the non-believer!!!

Hahaha jk

Vinnie · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Watchman

I believe we ALL have had to eat crow at some point in time rooting for the Texans.

I'm surprised crow isn't on the endangered species list thanks to Mario Williams!

thunderkyss · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr PC

I have seen many posts similar to this, all because one preseason performance. Schaub did look good vs the Saints playing the "lets throw at Jason David" game. But now everybody is jumping on his nuts because of one preseason game? If Sage happened to look better than Matt, the first thing I would expect to hear is "its just a preseason game." Now people are talking about Matt as a top 5 QB and comparing him to Tom Brady because he had a good preseason game.

I think you need to define "everybody"

Hooston Texan · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Texan

Yep thats me chomping on the crow over Sage being better than Matt. If we get the production from Matt for the remainder of theis season like we got saturday night then he hands down deserves the starting job. I know I was all in Sages corner but Matt just took it to the bank and deposited a gem.
So if all you I told you so's need to pile on me as I enjoy the crow feathers and all, then here ya go, let me have it.

If Matt produces in every game like he did against the Saints . . . he'll be the greatest QB who ever played. Nobody goes 14-for-16, 183, 2td's all the time (actually, it was 14-for-14 not counting Davis's drop and the throwaway Matt was forced in to when the screen pass was foiled), so I hope that's not the bar you are setting for what Matt has to do to definitively justify the trade and starting over Sage.

As a longtime, long-suffering UVA fan, I like to think of myself as the driver of the Matt Schaub bandwagon. I've been sold on his play since 2002. But what remains to be seen is whether he can survive an NFL season. At some point, the guy who can play all the time should start over the superior but physically-questionable player. Continuity is very important. Yes, the hits that hurt Schaub (apart from the Odom sack) were highly illegal, but we know that gutter-thugs like Albert Haynesworth and Drayton Florence would gladly give the 15 yards to knock Matt out again. Defensive coordinators everywhere would be greatful if they did.

Believe me, when it is time for the doubters to eat their bad-trade/start-Sage crow, I'll be the waiter. But I'm not sure dinner is served quite yet.

Hervoyel · 08-18-2008

Rep to anyone who admits to being wrong. One game doesn't prove it but that was a heck of a game.

CloakNNNdagger · 08-18-2008

I'll wait to call judgement until after the Girls game. If Schaub does separate himself, I still believe that Sage can pick up where Schaub leaves off if he gets injured later in the season. One thing not to forget (no seems to forget this in the hot RB competition discussions), when trying to judge the better of 2 players, you need to also factor in their ability to stay on the field. That ability can offset some minor deficiencies amongst players.

thunderkyss · 08-18-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hervoyel

Rep to anyone who admits to being wrong. One game doesn't prove it but that was a heck of a game.

Can't wait to see it

08-18-2008	#1
Joe Texan Inducted 04 Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: Spring Section: 116 row a seat 20 Age: 50 Posts: 9,784 Rep Power: 4089	Chomp Chomp Chomp Yep thats me chomping on the crow over Sage being better than Matt. If we get the production from Matt for the remainder of theis season like we got saturday night then he hands down deserves the starting job. I know I was all in Sages corner but Matt just took it to the bank and deposited a gem. So if all you I told you so's need to pile on me as I enjoy the crow feathers and all, then here ya go, let me have it. __________________ PRAYERS TO THE FALLEN AT FT. HOOD

08-18-2008	#3
gtexan02 Working? Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Boston Age: 29 Posts: 15,334 Rep Power: 34917	Re: Chomp Chomp Chomp I think Matt is better than Sage. But lets not forget the Saints had the 32 ranked pass defense last season __________________ Adios until next season. See you then

08-18-2008	#10
Brandon420tx Flounder Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Albuquerque, NM Age: 25 Posts: 3,870 Rep Power: 4417	Re: Chomp Chomp Chomp Greenwood has made me eat crow a few times. He's also made me spit it back out, I wish he would make up his mind. __________________ That Dolphin is the bravest thing I ever saw

08-18-2008	#13
Mr PC Hall of Fame Join Date: Aug 2007 Posts: 1,037 Rep Power: 19	Q I have seen many posts similar to this, all because one preseason performance. Schaub did look good vs the Saints playing the "lets throw at Jason David" game. But now everybody is jumping on his nuts because of one preseason game? If Sage happened to look better than Matt, the first thing I would expect to hear is "its just a preseason game." Now people are talking about Matt as a top 5 QB and comparing him to Tom Brady because he had a good preseason game. __________________ "We have a lot bigger package. I would say our package is probably twice as big as it was two years ago." - Sage Rosenfels, June 2008

08-18-2008	#14
Brandon420tx Flounder Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Albuquerque, NM Age: 25 Posts: 3,870 Rep Power: 4417	Re: Q Shun the non-believer!!! Hahaha jk __________________ That Dolphin is the bravest thing I ever saw

08-18-2008	#18
Hervoyel The Right Track Join Date: Apr 2004 Age: 47 Posts: 12,870 Rep Power: 57501	Re: Q Rep to anyone who admits to being wrong. One game doesn't prove it but that was a heck of a game. __________________ A wise man once said "...well at this point it's all been hashed out and you either see it or don't. Hoping for a win next week" - HTown2ATX

08-18-2008	#19
CloakNNNdagger Hall of Fame Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 12,454 Rep Power: 43447	Re: Chomp Chomp Chomp I'll wait to call judgement until after the Girls game. If Schaub does separate himself, I still believe that Sage can pick up where Schaub leaves off if he gets injured later in the season. One thing not to forget (no seems to forget this in the hot RB competition discussions), when trying to judge the better of 2 players, you need to also factor in their ability to stay on the field. That ability can offset some minor deficiencies amongst players.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Remove advertisements Sponsored links