Ranking the AFC South : QB's - Houston Texans Message Board & Forum

b0ng · 06-07-2008

This is a completely stolen idea from the GoTitans messageboards (I'm not posting the link, I'm sure you can find it elsewhere), but I am interested in seeing what we think of the rest of the AFC South as well as us. I want to do all of the units that will be on the field at any point, and I want to have a few days between each poll. I believe this will be a landslide by Manning, but I'll be interested in seeing if anybody disagree's and thinks Peyton might decline next season. Anyways here goes:

What QB in the AFC South do you consider the best?

brakos82 · 06-07-2008

I think PM will decline, but I don't see anybody else catching up to him this year. By 2009, either Schaub or Garrard could get him.

JCTexan · 06-07-2008

Manning is one of the best QB's in the game. Hard not to pick him here.

b0ng · 06-07-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by JCTexan

Manning is one of the best QB's in the game. Hard not to pick him here.

That's pretty much what I figured as well here, but you never know. I think the interesting polls will end up being the OL poll, the DL poll, and the WR poll. But that's just me.

**Brando** · 06-07-2008

Unfortunately we are in a divsion with one of the best QB's(Peyton Manning) of all time.

**ChampionTexan** · 06-07-2008

I can't really believe that anybody would legitimately select anybody other than Peyton. He's HOF bound, and still in the prime (late prime?) of his career. Nobody else in the division has even started two full seasons.

What may have been more interesting is to have a poll voting on the 2nd best QB in the division - and just to stir the pot, you could have included Sage in Mannings place.

b0ng · 06-07-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChampionTexan

What may have been more interesting is to have a poll voting on the 2nd best QB in the division - and just to stir the pot, you could have included Sage in Mannings place.

You know, there's a special place in hell reserved for you.

GuerillaBlack · 06-07-2008

This shouldn't even be a contest...

It is easily Vince Young.

**Double Barrel** · 06-07-2008

Manning will be the best in the AFC South until he retires. An old PM is better than any of the other three in their prime. He's HoF without even thinking about it.

b0ng · 06-07-2008

It seems that at least the Texans fans are pretty unbiased when it comes to QB'ing. We all know who the best in the division is, and he doesn't wear steel blue and battle red. I'll leave this poll open for the rest of today and I'll start a new one tommorrow. What unit would you guys like to see get ranked? I'm thinking either defensive lines, or offensive lines. Something much more muddled than the QB's.

**ChampionTexan** · 06-07-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by b0ng

You know, there's a special place in hell reserved for you.

Aw C'mon - it's the low-point of the year. Draft 6 weeks ago, TC is 6 or 7 weeks away - gotta do something to keep it interesting.

Seriously, I love both Schaub and Sage, but completely agree with the Teams decision that Schaub is the clear and undisputed starter. Just need to have him healthy all season.

Goldensilence · 06-07-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by brakos82

I think PM will decline, but I don't see anybody else catching up to him this year. By 2009, either Schaub or Garrard could get him.

Garrard? Not even close. I see Schaub as a Hasselbeck type of guy.

No one is going to catch him even after he retires in our division.

**SheTexan** · 06-07-2008

A no brainer, IMO! 100% PM, for now anyway.

b0ng · 06-07-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChampionTexan

Aw C'mon - it's the low-point of the year. Draft 6 weeks ago, TC is 6 or 7 weeks away - gotta do something to keep it interesting.

Seriously, I love both Schaub and Sage, but completely agree with the Teams decision that Schaub is the clear and undisputed starter. Just need to have him healthy all season.

I was just messing, but honestly, if it wasn't such a beaten to death subject, I probably would've done it that way. But there's other units that I think will probably be landslides as well. I mean, when I do the RB's poll, I think the Jacksonville RB combo of Taylor/Jones-Drew is probably going to win in a landslide as well. I'll keep all the polls the same so that way other teams fans won't feel left out, and we'll consider everybody. I wish there was a way to post something similar to a poll, but have everybody rank the players instead, and then the average of everybody's rankings is displayed as how the Texans fans think the QB's in the South rank in order.

But I don't think we have that software here.

HJam72 · 06-07-2008

Don't you people know you're s'posed ta be homers?

b0ng · 06-07-2008

Quote:

Originally Posted by HJam72

Don't you people know you're s'posed ta be homers?

Homer picks would probably go over better in this poll

The Pencil Neck · 06-07-2008

I was just over on the Jag's site and there was a poll for strongest team in the league. Of course, they had the Jag's as the hands down best.

I really want to sweep them again this year.

**ObsiWan** · 06-07-2008

Manning is the top QB in the division...
but
One does wonder what Garrard could do with A.J./K.W. or Wayne/Harrison to throw to.
....or Kubiak coaching him up
....or Tom Matte planning his offense

View Poll Results: Best QB in the AFC South
Peyton Manning	32	96.97%
Vince Young	0	0%
Matt Schaub	1	3.03%
David Garrard	0	0%
Voters: 33. You may not vote on this poll

06-07-2008	#1
b0ng Ooops Join Date: Jul 2007 Age: 32 Posts: 6,837 Rep Power: 27461	Ranking the AFC South : QB's This is a completely stolen idea from the GoTitans messageboards (I'm not posting the link, I'm sure you can find it elsewhere), but I am interested in seeing what we think of the rest of the AFC South as well as us. I want to do all of the units that will be on the field at any point, and I want to have a few days between each poll. I believe this will be a landslide by Manning, but I'll be interested in seeing if anybody disagree's and thinks Peyton might decline next season. Anyways here goes: What QB in the AFC South do you consider the best?

06-07-2008	#2
brakos82 Hall of Fame Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: LOHAR (Land of Hipsters and Rain) Section: 1009 E. Union Age: 30 Posts: 19,392 Rep Power: 32569	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's I think PM will decline, but I don't see anybody else catching up to him this year. By 2009, either Schaub or Garrard could get him.

06-07-2008	#3
JCTexan Hall of Fame Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Austin Age: 24 Posts: 2,924 Rep Power: 7266	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's Manning is one of the best QB's in the game. Hard not to pick him here.

06-07-2008	#5
Brando Site Contributor Join Date: Apr 2007 Posts: 6,573 Rep Power: 1664	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's Unfortunately we are in a divsion with one of the best QB's(Peyton Manning) of all time. __________________ Extra Special Thanks to False Start for the signature!

06-07-2008	#6
ChampionTexan Site Contributor Join Date: Nov 2007 Posts: 4,333 Rep Power: 25874	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's I can't really believe that anybody would legitimately select anybody other than Peyton. He's HOF bound, and still in the prime (late prime?) of his career. Nobody else in the division has even started two full seasons. What may have been more interesting is to have a poll voting on the 2nd best QB in the division - and just to stir the pot, you could have included Sage in Mannings place.

06-07-2008	#8
GuerillaBlack Hall of Fame Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Dee Eff Dub Age: 21 Posts: 8,760 Rep Power: 6323	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's This shouldn't even be a contest... It is easily Vince Young.

06-07-2008	#9
Double Barrel Moderator Join Date: Oct 2004 Section: Gridiron, Texas Age: 46 Posts: 27,095 Rep Power: 82546	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's Manning will be the best in the AFC South until he retires. An old PM is better than any of the other three in their prime. He's HoF without even thinking about it. __________________ "FOOTBALL IS ONLY A DIVERSION." ~ HOUSTON TEXANS In Memoriam - 20 little angels

06-07-2008	#10
b0ng Ooops Join Date: Jul 2007 Age: 32 Posts: 6,837 Rep Power: 27461	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's It seems that at least the Texans fans are pretty unbiased when it comes to QB'ing. We all know who the best in the division is, and he doesn't wear steel blue and battle red. I'll leave this poll open for the rest of today and I'll start a new one tommorrow. What unit would you guys like to see get ranked? I'm thinking either defensive lines, or offensive lines. Something much more muddled than the QB's.

06-07-2008	#15
HJam72 Hall of Fame Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Over here. Age: 40 Posts: 10,472 Rep Power: 18004	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's Don't you people know you're s'posed ta be homers? __________________

06-07-2008	#17
The Pencil Neck Hall of Fame Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: Dallas, TX Age: 51 Posts: 14,429 Rep Power: 45686	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's I was just over on the Jag's site and there was a poll for strongest team in the league. Of course, they had the Jag's as the hands down best. I really want to sweep them again this year.

06-07-2008	#18
ObsiWan Contributor Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: League City, Tx Age: 61 Posts: 10,073 Rep Power: 37218	Re: Ranking the AFC South : QB's Manning is the top QB in the division... but One does wonder what Garrard could do with A.J./K.W. or Wayne/Harrison to throw to. ....or Kubiak coaching him up ....or Tom Matte planning his offense

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Remove advertisements Sponsored links