Trade idea

[Lifetime Oiler/Texan Fan]

This is purely an idea. We package a trade of Carr, Babin, our 3rd round pick and next years 3rd round pick to Miami for their first (9th overall) pick in this years draft. Miami get their starting QB and DE help that they need with extra picks to match the 9th overall pick's worth. I think everyone is agreed that we need 5 starters (S, OT, CB, WR, and DL). With the 9th and 10th overall pick, we would be able to solidly fill two of those positions. In this trade, Miami now with a starting QB will release Culpepper. Oakland would instantly sign him for their starter. This would dramatically change the top 10 draft selections. It most likely would look like this.

1. Oakland - Johnson/WR
2. Detroit - Quinn/QB
3. Cleveland - Russel/QB
4. Tampa Bay - Thomas/OT
5. Arizona - Peterson/RB
6. Washington - Adams/DE
7. Minnesota - Landry/S
8. Atlanta - Branch/DT

That leaves us to pick two of these players:

Amobi Okoyi - DT
Jamaal Anderson - DE
Levi Brown - OT
Leon Hall - CB
Ted Ginn, JR - WR
Dewayne Bowe - WR

I personally would go with Okoyi and Hall, but any one of these player would start for us for many years to come.

[AtheGreat]

if that would ever happen...yeah, i'd do it. will it? nope.

[Vinny]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M4nZmYYwzSI I couldn't find the Real Men of Genius Ridiculous trade proposal guy vid.

[michaelm]

Originally Posted by Vinny

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M4nZmYYwzSI

You only say that because you couldn't find a link to "Mr. Preposterous Trade Suggester Guy"...

[Spike]

I think that this is a cool idea, but it makes me laugh as it reminds me of that "trade suggestor" commercial that you always hear on the radio...if you add the Dolphins waterboy to this equation, it would be an epic post.

[Second Honeymoon]

'we'll throw in the trainer!!'

Personally, I think we should try and package Carr and a conditional 2nd day pick to Oakland for Randy Moss. I know it sounds crazy but its pretty much the only deal you will see unless Carr restructures.

[STEEL BLUE TEXANS]

Originally Posted by Vinny

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M4nZmYYwzSI I couldn't find the Real Men of Genius Ridiculous trade proposal guy vid.

http://media.putfile.com/SR610---Mra...rade-Suggestor

[Blu]

dang..you must of been one of those guys that wanted to trade carr last yr to N.O. and pick #1 and #2 (VY and Bush)

[STEEL BLUE TEXANS]

This is hilarious...


http://sportsradio610.com/play_windo...audioId=473881

[Killer Bee]

We still need to build through the draft, and we need our second pick back. I would like to see us package Carr and our third round pick to any team in need of poor QB play. Possibly Cleveland bites. That would give us a quality starter at the 35th overall pick and relieve us from Carr's hefty contract.

[Dallas_Texan]

It would never happen, but I would take Reggie Nelson and Marshawn Lynch. If not Lynch, then I would go Leon Hall and Reggie Nelson. With that combo and Dunta Robinson the secondary would be set for the next 8 years.

Reggie Nelson is far better (FOR US) than Laron Landry. Landry is a Strong Safety, and a darn good one, but Nelson is better as a Free Safety, which is what Faggins showed us we needed against the Bills in 2006.

[Malloy]

What about we offer our remaining picks this year and next to get Vince Young and Reggie Bush, we would be so bad-ass!

[Bubbajwp]

Or we could doe somthing a little bit realistic and trade Carr and our third or fourth round pick for a second round pick.

[gjmac2]

Originally Posted by Killer Bee

We still need to build through the draft, and we need our second pick back. I would like to see us package Carr and our third round pick to any team in need of poor QB play. Possibly Cleveland bites. That would give us a quality starter at the 35th overall pick and relieve us from Carr's hefty contract.

I think we should trade down again in the 1st round, and try and recoup one of the 2nd round picks we surrendered in the Schaub deal. I think we can go down as far as 20, and still get Reggie Nelson.

[Vinny]

Originally Posted by Bubbajwp

Or we could doe somthing a little bit realistic and trade Carr and our third or fourth round pick for a second round pick.

would take Joey Harrington and a 4th for our second round pick?

[infantrycak]

Originally Posted by Dallas_Texan

Landry is a Strong Safety

Since when? Dude is a free safety.

[Dallas_Texan]

Originally Posted by infantrycak

Since when? Dude is a free safety.

Not in the NFL. He's a hard hitter, but he's not as good in coverage as Nelson. He may get picked up as a FS somewhere, but most people will convert him to SS.

[infantrycak]

Originally Posted by Dallas_Texan

Not in the NFL. He's a hard hitter, but he's not as good in coverage as Nelson. He may get picked up as a FS somewhere, but most people will convert him to SS.

Dunta Robinson hits hard--doesn't make him a SS. The fact that there may be another player who covers better also doesn't make him a SS.

Originally Posted by Dallas_Texan

Not in the NFL. He's a hard hitter, but he's not as good in coverage as Nelson. He may get picked up as a FS somewhere, but most people will convert him to SS.

Where do you get your info from ?



My advice would be to find another source.

[powerfuldragon]

Originally Posted by STEEL BLUE TEXANS

This is hilarious...


http://sportsradio610.com/play_windo...audioId=473881

oh my goodness. that's the most convoluted scheme I've ever wasted my time listening to.