You like Schaub over Carr? - Houston Texans Message Board & Forum

valleytexfan · 03-22-2007

Yay or nay...simple.

mikey21 · 03-22-2007

undecided

**Andrew6** · 03-22-2007

maybe

WaywardTexanFan · 03-22-2007

TIme will tell...

texans83 · 03-22-2007

im still kinda scared

Pantherstang84 · 03-22-2007

I like it because Kubiak/Smith decided it was best for the franchise.

HJam72 · 03-22-2007

I have to say yes, but I don't know how much better he is.

canadiantexan · 03-22-2007

I'll tell you in December.

**Hookem Horns** · 03-22-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pantherstang84

I like it because Kubiak/Smith decided it was best for the franchise.

They decided Carr was better for the franchise last season and passed up 3 potentially great QBs. However I do feel a little better about this decision.

valleytexfan · 03-22-2007

interesting, guys

Huge · 03-22-2007

Still undecided.

I think at worst he will be at least as good as Carr. Problem is with what was given up to get him (those two 2nd round picks) he needs to be considerably better.

My Hero · 03-22-2007

I voted NO!

Listining to the commentary about this trade,people are saying why?
He's less mobile than Carr, you don't even know what he's capable of. He's too unknown. No wins, 6 TD's and 6 int's.

I said it before however, that I will bow to the decisions made by the FO and coaching and I'm a man of my word. Welcome to Houston Matt Schaub.

Pip · 03-22-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by My Hero

I voted NO!

Listining to the commentary about this trade,people are saying why?
He's less mobile than Carr, you don't even know what he's capable of. He's too unknown. No wins, 6 TD's and 6 int's.

I said it before however, that I will bow to the decisions made by the FO and coaching and I'm a man of my word. Welcome to Houston Matt Schaub.

I have seen him play twice and I thought he was very mobile. I looked up the game in 2005 against the vikings (where I first became impressed by him) and he had 4 carries for 56 yards. The guy can run--he may not be michael vick, but he sure isn't drew bledsoe either.

As for the original question, I would take Schaub over at least 1/3 of the current starting QBs in the NFL.

kcwilson · 03-22-2007

Removing the picks we gave up, removing the salary questions I have related to the cap... and purely on which guy i would feel most comfortable with in getting this team to win right now... I say Schaub. We have seen Carr, we know what we will get.

Time will tell about the picks and salary, but I am excited for the organization to move on from the expansion mentality days.

**Double Barrel** · 03-22-2007

Straight up: yes.

We know what we have in Carr. While there is uncertaintly with Shaub, we know he has some intangibles that we've never seen from a Texans QB. Those alone make him an upgrade, IMO.

wags · 03-22-2007

I'm happy for Carr that he can finally get out of Houston. It will be better for everyone. Change, in this case, is very good for everyone.

I think Schaub could play better than Carr has here, but that ain't saying much.

DocBar · 03-22-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pantherstang84

I like it because Kubiak/Smith decided it was best for the franchise.

You must still have some Casserly/Capers Kool aid.
I still can't decide if I like it or not.

VICKTMS · 03-22-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by wags

I'm happy for Carr that he can finally get out of Houston. It will be better for everyone. Change, in this case, is very good for everyone.

I think Schaub could play better than Carr has here, but that ain't saying much.

HAHAHAAHAHAHAHA OOOOHHHHH SNAP!!!! I think Schaub is good but DAMN!!!! Thank you guys for the picks and the swap! We are going to make some serious additions to our roster with those...maybe even CALVIN JOHNSON!!!! I can't believe you gave up all that and then paid that guy....(6tds and 6ints 81 out of 161 passes) that kinda money!!! He is just like CARR but slower...weak arm too, so don't expect to be stretching the field with AJohnson. We(the Falcons) and our new additions(Calvin, Landry, Levi, Nelson, Bush..who knows) will see you next yr. for the beating of your life!!!

ATLANTA 34 TEXANS 13

TheRealX9 · 03-22-2007

as a back up for carr? hell yeah!

bigTEXan8 · 03-22-2007

there isn't enough evidence to say that schaub is better than carr. the only thing schaub has over carr is not having the krap kicked out of him for the past 5 years.

View Poll Results: You like Schaub over Carr?
Yes	71	75.53%
No	23	24.47%
Voters: 94. You may not vote on this poll

03-22-2007	#1
valleytexfan Hall of Fame Join Date: May 2006 Location: Rio Grande Valley, TX Posts: 1,141 Rep Power: 274	You like Schaub over Carr? Yay or nay...simple.

03-22-2007	#2
mikey21 Lifer Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: H-Town Posts: 91 Rep Power: 8	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? undecided __________________ Everything is Bigger and Better in Texas

03-22-2007	#3
Andrew6 Site Contributor Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: League City Age: 31 Posts: 3,092 Rep Power: 4660	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? maybe __________________ Daily Thought: SOME PEOPLE ARE LIKE SLINKYS. NOT REALLY GOOD FOR ANYTHING BUT THEY BRING A SMILE TO YOUR FACE WHEN PUSHED DOWN THE STAIRS.

03-22-2007	#4
WaywardTexanFan Veteran Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: Maryland Age: 51 Posts: 155 Rep Power: 7	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? TIme will tell...

03-22-2007	#5
texans83 All Pro Join Date: Nov 2006 Location: Friendswood Age: 30 Posts: 735 Rep Power: 8	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? im still kinda scared

03-22-2007	#6
Pantherstang84 @rolisrgti06 Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 3,894 Rep Power: 3455	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? I like it because Kubiak/Smith decided it was best for the franchise.

03-22-2007	#7
HJam72 Hall of Fame Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Over here. Age: 40 Posts: 10,472 Rep Power: 18004	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? I have to say yes, but I don't know how much better he is. __________________

03-22-2007	#8
canadiantexan Veteran Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: St.George, Ontario Age: 32 Posts: 300 Rep Power: 9	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? I'll tell you in December.

03-22-2007	#10
valleytexfan Hall of Fame Join Date: May 2006 Location: Rio Grande Valley, TX Posts: 1,141 Rep Power: 274	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? interesting, guys

03-22-2007	#11
Huge Hall of Fame Join Date: May 2004 Location: Out yonder way... Age: 41 Posts: 2,386 Rep Power: 15	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? Still undecided. I think at worst he will be at least as good as Carr. Problem is with what was given up to get him (those two 2nd round picks) he needs to be considerably better.

03-22-2007	#12
My Hero Veteran Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Clovis, CA Age: 32 Posts: 103 Rep Power: 7	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? I voted NO! Listining to the commentary about this trade,people are saying why? He's less mobile than Carr, you don't even know what he's capable of. He's too unknown. No wins, 6 TD's and 6 int's. I said it before however, that I will bow to the decisions made by the FO and coaching and I'm a man of my word. Welcome to Houston Matt Schaub. __________________ Carr Homer

03-22-2007	#14
kcwilson All Pro Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Los Angeles-area Age: 39 Posts: 607 Rep Power: 11	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? Removing the picks we gave up, removing the salary questions I have related to the cap... and purely on which guy i would feel most comfortable with in getting this team to win right now... I say Schaub. We have seen Carr, we know what we will get. Time will tell about the picks and salary, but I am excited for the organization to move on from the expansion mentality days. __________________ Post-Schaub Xmas List: (1) Landry/Nelson, (3) Satele, (4) DE/DT, (5) CB

03-22-2007	#15
Double Barrel Moderator Join Date: Oct 2004 Section: Gridiron, Texas Age: 46 Posts: 27,053 Rep Power: 81571	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? Straight up: yes. We know what we have in Carr. While there is uncertaintly with Shaub, we know he has some intangibles that we've never seen from a Texans QB. Those alone make him an upgrade, IMO. __________________ "FOOTBALL IS ONLY A DIVERSION." ~ HOUSTON TEXANS In Memoriam - 20 little angels

03-22-2007	#16
wags Hall of Fame Join Date: May 2004 Location: TX and FL Age: 34 Posts: 1,601 Rep Power: 22	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? I'm happy for Carr that he can finally get out of Houston. It will be better for everyone. Change, in this case, is very good for everyone. I think Schaub could play better than Carr has here, but that ain't saying much. __________________ A good argument is always spoiled by someone who knows what they're talking about

Remove advertisements Sponsored links

03-22-2007	#19
TheRealX9 Rookie Join Date: Oct 2006 Location: Corpus Christi, Tx Posts: 24 Rep Power: 0	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? as a back up for carr? hell yeah! __________________ THE CARR FAN.

03-22-2007	#20
bigTEXan8 All Pro Join Date: May 2005 Location: The 'No, CA Age: 30 Posts: 919 Rep Power: 9	Re: You like Schaub over Carr? there isn't enough evidence to say that schaub is better than carr. the only thing schaub has over carr is not having the krap kicked out of him for the past 5 years. __________________ The Lord is my refuge and strength, an ever present help in trouble.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode