I know you're disappointed....

[Titanic]

But I just want to say that was a great game. I know we put up a lot of yards but your defense is looking better and I don't understand why you guys hate on Carr so much. He's not amazing but he's accurate and he's tough, I don't see why he gets so much crap with your line and freaking Ron Dayne and Lundy at RB. This rivalry is going to be fun the next few years, good luck the rest of the season.

[Silver Oak]

You're right, we are disappointed, but thanks for the good words.

[TexSon]

Originally Posted by Titanic

But I just want to say that was a great game. I know we put up a lot of yards but your defense is looking better and I don't understand why you guys hate on Carr so much. He's not amazing but he's accurate and he's tough, I don't see why he gets so much crap with your line and freaking Ron Dayne and Lundy at RB. This rivalry is going to be fun the next few years, good luck the rest of the season.

Dayne was the ONLY reason we were in this game from an offensive standpoint. Carr did nothing but make no terrible mistakes. Whoopdeedo

[stingray]

Originally Posted by Titanic

But I just want to say that was a great game. I know we put up a lot of yards but your defense is looking better and I don't understand why you guys hate on Carr so much. He's not amazing but he's accurate and he's tough, I don't see why he gets so much crap with your line and freaking Ron Dayne and Lundy at RB. This rivalry is going to be fun the next few years, good luck the rest of the season.

You don't understand cause you don't have him on your team...

[Goldeagle]

Carr did not lose this game for us. Our D line dissapeared and Kubiak had some bonehead calls again. #80 dropped a few more passes and no one could find Dayne in the 2nd half.

Great win by VY, weve seen it so many times. We got beat by a better team, and that is all.

[TexanLen]

It is very disappointing!!! I look around the league and see 3rd, 2nd, and rookie Qb's coming in and looking better than Carr. Even when Carr had time, he wasn't spectacular. All his yards are mostly YAC. He has a good percentage because he dumps and dinks. He just wore out his welcome here. He is a great guy and it is no crack on him as a person, but he needs to go!!!

[MrMeToo]

Originally Posted by Goldeagle

Carr did not lose this game for us. Our D line dissapeared and Kubiak had some bonehead calls again. #80 dropped a few more passes and no one could find Dayne in the 2nd half.

Great win by VY, weve seen it so many times. We got beat by a better team, and that is all.

Andre almost save Carr's career at the end of the game. Also, the one pass Andre dropped he was held. Stop not blaming Carr. Carr is done. He's not a winner like VINCE YOUNG. Maybe when Carr goes to another team next season, you cheer him on over there.

[TexanLen]

I think Dayne waanted to be 1st at the Buffet table. He started standing in line at half time.

[Austrian]

Fact is we were swept by the Titans for the 2nd consecutive season. So what rivalery.

[Reddevil63]

Originally Posted by Goldeagle

Carr did not lose this game for us. Our D line dissapeared and Kubiak had some bonehead calls again. #80 dropped a few more passes and no one could find Dayne in the 2nd half.

Great win by VY, weve seen it so many times. We got beat by a better team, and that is all.

Nope he didnt lose it, but he certainly didnt win it either. If you have a consistant running game picking up good yardage, then you can get away with a QB who cant make big plays.

[Goldeagle]

Originally Posted by MrMeToo

Andre almost save Carr's career at the end of the game. Also, the one pass Andre dropped he was held. Stop not blaming Carr. Carr is done. He's not a winner like VINCE YOUNG. Maybe when Carr goes to another team next season, you cheer him on over there.

ANd Andre has DROPPED plenty of passes. #80 is not free of blame.

AND LOL about your comment cheering Carr on another team...Like you are doing for VY...loser.

[Goldeagle]

Originally Posted by Reddevil63

Nope he didnt lose it, but he certainly didnt win it either. If you have a consistant running game picking up good yardage, then you can get away with a QB who cant make big plays.

Yup, we cant throw deep because our O-line play stinks and oru Run game dissapeared.

[wolfscar]

Originally Posted by Titanic

I don't understand why you guys hate on Carr so much. He's not amazing but he's accurate and he's tough, I don't see why he gets so much crap with your line and freaking Ron Dayne and Lundy at RB.

Don't even bother, my friend. Doesn't matter what Carr does in the game - if we don't win he gets slated. Period. I guess that's what happens when you get a paycheck the size of his - if you're not spectacularly good then you're worthless. Maybe justifiably so.

Interesting comparison ...
TODAY:
V. Young - 19 of 29 - 218yds - 65.5% - 1 INT - one rushing TD against a Defense that should have stopped that play in its sleep. Titans win. Texans message board filled with people posting that Vince is god.

5th NOVEMBER:
D. Carr - 21 of 30 - 176yds - 70.0% - 0 INT - one gutsy rushing TD against one of the best rush defenses in the league. Giants win. Texans message board barely mentions Carr except to talk about poor play in the first half.

I'm not suggesting that the guy shouldn't be scrutinised, but this game was not lost because of Carr. If you want to condense it down it was lost on one shocking defensive play and some ultra-conservative play calling from Kubiak. I'll be very interested to see what happens here in the offseason because he's not putting a drop of faith in his QB.

[wolfscar]

Originally Posted by Austrian

Fact is we were swept by the Titans for the 2nd consecutive season. So what rivalery.

The Jags whipped the Colts today, so if we beat Peyton and co. in two weeks they'll have lost to all four teams this year. That would be a nice way to round out the season. Not a particularly likely way, but a nice way.

[Goldeagle]

As I posted, if Carr does not go for over 72% and 320 yards he had a bad game. He has a bad game every week, Carr haters were crying about every game like the Raiders game where he had -7 yards. So I had to figure his best statistical game and realized anything over that is a good game

[TexanLen]

Originally Posted by Goldeagle

As I posted, if Carr does not go for over 72% and 320 yards he had a bad game. He has a bad game every week, Carr haters were crying about every game like the Raiders game where he had -7 yards. So I had to figure his best statistical game and realized anything over that is a good game

No, Carr is not a good QB. Most of his yards are YAC. The 5 yard dumps are nothing for a NFL QB. Carr cannot lead his team to victory.

How many people had confidence that Carr would lead this team to victory? I bet nearly every fan had more confidence that VY would have a better chance to bring his team back than Carr did.

We are the laughing stock of the NFL right now. This loss hurts!!!

[Goldeagle]

Originally Posted by TexanLen

No, Carr is not a good QB. Most of his yards are YAC. The 5 yard dumps are nothing for a NFL QB. Carr cannot lead his team to victory.

How many people had confidence that Carr would lead this team to victory? I bet nearly every fan had more confidence that VY would have a better chance to bring his team back than Carr did.

We are the laughing stock of the NFL right now. This loss hurts!!!

As Ive posted. Dropped passes hurt Carr. Cook fumbling inside of 2 minutes hurts Carr.

I recall beating the Jags on 4th and 1 one year. He can win, but the O-line has to improve, thats how the Cowboys won along with the Niners and so on.

I have to agree with you about the short passing game, but I question is that to supplement the pathetic run game and to protect Carr because of bad O-line play?

[TheCD]

Originally Posted by MrMeToo

Carr is done. He's not a winner like VINCE YOUNG.

Last I checked both Vince Young and David Carr have won at least one game in their careers...thus making them winers.

1 TD in 7 games. I'm sorry but that kills me.

[Goldeagle]

Originally Posted by Ckw5814

1 TD in 7 games. I'm sorry but that kills me.

Hey, Carrs stats did not count when he played well, so they dont count if he has not produced as much as the start of the season (Remember its about wins)