The Official "I got Carr's back" thread

[Tulip]

Originally Posted by New_Texans

*shakes head and hides in corner*

what was I smoking?

Don't worry - we all had our own epiphany moments at different times.

Besides, David didn't truly prove any of us right until he changed uniforms.

[Corrosion]

How bout someone just dig a hole and throw Carr and this thread in it ! .... And dont forget to cover it up !

[hollywood_texan]

This is great!

What a laugh to go through this thread.

Put this thread on a sticky...

[Honoring Earl 34]

Originally Posted by New_Texans

*shakes head and hides in corner*

what was I smoking?

Some of you guys broke a baseball record in this thread .

It has something to do with how many times Yogi Berra was hit on the chin with baseballs .

[TexanSam]

Boo! I never posted in this thread

[adam]

Wow. It must be pretty embarassing to look back at this thread if you were a Carr lover.

[TEXANRED]

Originally Posted by TexanSam

Boo! I never posted in this thread

Hey neither did I. Oh wait, we both just did.

[Honoring Earl 34]

Originally Posted by adam

Wow. It must be pretty embarassing to look back at this thread if you were a Carr lover.

Hmmm ... more fanatical than a Hannah Montana fan maybe .

[brakos82]

(insert other smilie here)

[Runner]

I don't see the point in resurrecting this thread, especially since if we went back 2 more years, Carr was the hero of 98% of the people on this board.

It is interesting to look at this thread in relation to the Mario threads of today though.

“Those who cannot study history, are doomed to repeat it.” – George Santayana

[brakos82]

Didn't Carr line up under the guard once?

My original typing was full of so many mistakes.

[TexansSeminole]

Originally Posted by Runner

I don't see the point in resurrecting this thread, especially since if we went back 2 more years, Carr was the hero of 98% of the people on this board.

It is interesting to look at this thread in relation to the Mario threads of today though.

I just thought it was kind of funny how things change so quickly.

[Honoring Earl 34]

Originally Posted by TexansSeminole

I just thought it was kind of funny how things change so quickly.

This thread was a response to a get rid of Carr thread .

[TexansSeminole]

Originally Posted by Honoring Earl 34

This thread was a response to a get rid of Carr thread .

I know, but this thread was still representative of alot of people, even during the middle of last season.

[Texan_Bill]

Originally Posted by Runner

I don't see the point in resurrecting this thread, especially since if we went back 2 more years, Carr was the hero of 98% of the people on this board.

It is interesting to look at this thread in relation to the Mario threads of today though.

Are you one of those people that can not accept when the masses admit they were wrong....

[Vinny]

I think everyone knows why I never posted in this thread.

[Texanmike02]

I'm all for digging up "this is an 9 or 10 win season threads from the beginning of the year."


Oh and for what its worth I still say WE RUINED CARR. He might not have been a probowler but I'm pretty sure whatever chance he had at making it in the nfl was dragged through the dirt, burned at the steak and the farted on by the C&C Crap factory we had running things here.

Mike

[Vinny]

Originally Posted by Texanmike

I'm all for digging up "this is an 9 or 10 win season threads from the beginning of the year."


Oh and for what its worth I still say WE RUINED CARR. He might not have been a probowler but I'm pretty sure whatever chance he had at making it in the nfl was dragged through the dirt, burned at the steak and the farted on by the C&C Crap factory we had running things here.

Mike

I don't think we "ruined" him...it's possible he was bad the whole time here. I was villified back in 2003 for just stating what I was observing. If you notice, I was pointing out problems with his game long before most of our fans were even trying to acknowledge he had any.

[Tulip]

I wasn't very surprised to see my absence from this thread either.

Oh, how I miss the Fresno fans.

Wait - no I don't.

[Texanmike02]

Originally Posted by Vinny

I don't think we "ruined" him...it's possible he was bad the whole time here. I was villified back in 2003 for just stating what I was observing. If you notice, I was pointing out problems with his game long before most of our fans were even trying to acknowledge he had any.

Well there were several problems with that team. And I'm not saying he was a top 5 potential QB. At the same time, its well documented that he was told who to throw the ball to. He wasn't checking down from one receiver to the next etc. when he first came into the league. I think the coaching was horrible because not only did his decision making get worse, so did his accuracy and his touch. Go back and watch some of his early games. He was making rookie mistakes. He was holding onto the ball too long, but he was also throwing passes on target.

I remember several occasions early in his career when he made football decisions. By the end here, he was running for his life. There was a game against the Rams, I think, his rookie year when he was getting drug down in the end zone and managed to stretch the ball out and get it over the goal line as he was going down. That is a smart football play. I'm not saying he was a rocket scientist, but rather that I watched both his physical talents degrade and his IQ diminished every year. We talked bout him developing, but when a QB leaves a place and is a worse QB than when he arrived as a rookie.... that's not good.

Mike