Under Review?????? - Houston Texans Message Board & Forum

Speedy · 09-19-2004

I realize we gave the game away on turnovers AGAIN....but AJ was pushed out of bounds at the 1 and there was no review. What gives??? I mean it may have been too little too late, but we score from 1 yard out, you can at least try the onsides kick and if we got it, we still had 3 timeouts.

rhc564 · 09-19-2004

...get use to it, buddy, it's going to be a long year

ATX · 09-19-2004

i still don't get that call. it's under 2 minutes and a disputable play, where were the guys who make that decision. fire them now

Fiddy · 09-19-2004

there is no challenge for a force out call....

**texasguy346** · 09-19-2004

The ref blew the call, but like Fiddy said there is no review for a force out call. It's up to the referree on the field to judge. I don't understand the rule, but apparently thats how the NFL does it.

thetexanator · 09-19-2004

the texans should complain to the league

Speedy · 09-19-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fiddy

there is no challenge for a force out call....

Then it was a sorry ****ing call.

texansfan88 · 09-19-2004

according to the self proclaimed experts on this board, we really suck so it wouldnt of mattered anyway.

Mistril48 · 09-19-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fiddy

there is no challenge for a force out call....

I thought this also, but at the end of the Tacks game, they reviewed a force of call on the 1 yrd line ... so I'm confused.

**Vinny** · 09-19-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mistril48

I thought this also, but at the end of the Tacks game, they reviewed a force of call on the 1 yrd line ... so I'm confused.

They were only looking at possession of the ball. They were not ruling on the judgement aspect of the force out.

Reddevil63 · 09-19-2004

it was a good catch though

jacquescas · 09-19-2004

I'm happy Carr is making strides, if Davis can't control his fumbling we still have Hollings that is promising. I don't expect more than 5 wins this season.

rittenhouserobz · 09-19-2004

The guys upstairs should have challenged the catch not the push out of bounds, but in reality the premise of instant replay is too ensure that a bad play isn't called.

HJam72 · 09-19-2004

OK, that's it. Fire the refs, Capers, Casserly, Palmer, the rest of the coaches, DD, Dunta, and anyone else who has an attitude. Nah, just fire that one ref and PUT DD ON THE FREAKING BENCH!

Mistril48 · 09-19-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vinny

They were only looking at possession of the ball. They were not ruling on the judgement aspect of the force out.

Thanks. I had the sound down and didn't hear what they said. I just saw them reviewing something.

Jwwillis · 09-19-2004

The way I understood it the Texans couldnt challenge in the last 2 minuets only the officials could. The officials didnt challenge it because the force out rule in un-challengable.

bossbfan · 09-19-2004

As a Lions fan I actually felt a little dirty when the ref blew that call on Andre's catch. I want the Lions to win, but not on bad calls. You still would have had to get the onside kick, plus score another TD, but you should have had a shot at it. I also would have liked to have seen if the Lions could have stopped the Texans at the 1 YD line.

I think the worst play of the game was when the Texans went for 2 with like 15min left in the game. That was a BAD coaching decision. Very panicky.

wags · 09-19-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by bossbfan

I think the worst play of the game was when the Texans went for 2 with like 15min left in the game. That was a BAD coaching decision. Very panicky.

Yea, I have always heard that you never "chase" points. With 12 minutes left I was not happy to see them go for 2.

JustBonee · 09-19-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by wags

Yea, I have always heard that you never "chase" points. With 12 minutes left I was not happy to see them go for 2.

In that instance, it wasn't a bad coaching decision, because if they had made the 2 points and then had gotten a field goal after that, the game would have been tied.
But other than that call ... the rest of the coaching decisions were the pits!

JDizzle · 09-19-2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by bossbfan

I think the worst play of the game was when the Texans went for 2 with like 15min left in the game. That was a BAD coaching decision. Very panicky.

That wasn't a "panicky" decision at all. Capers was just trying to get within a field goal from evening the score. If you look at the scenarios it makes sense.

A) Kick the PAT, you're down 4 points and need a touchdown to go ahead.
B) Go for 2, fail, you're down 5, yet you still need a touchdown to go ahead.
C) Go for 2, succeed, you're down 3 and within a field goal of evening things up.

In that case going for 2 isn't a very big risk, even in the 4th quarter.

09-19-2004	#1
Speedy Yeller Dweller Join Date: May 2004 Location: The Livable Forest Section: 547 - Row A - Dark Side Posts: 2,853 Rep Power: 9713	Under Review?????? I realize we gave the game away on turnovers AGAIN....but AJ was pushed out of bounds at the 1 and there was no review. What gives??? I mean it may have been too little too late, but we score from 1 yard out, you can at least try the onsides kick and if we got it, we still had 3 timeouts. __________________ *thatsbulltailgaters.net*

09-19-2004	#4
Fiddy Hall of Fame Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Houston/Austin Age: 25 Posts: 4,314 Rep Power: 17	there is no challenge for a force out call.... __________________ 'Anyone ready to go outside so I can make you look bad?' - Matt Schaub talking to the DBs

09-19-2004	#13
rittenhouserobz Hall of Fame Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 1,100 Rep Power: 11	The guys upstairs should have challenged the catch not the push out of bounds, but in reality the premise of instant replay is too ensure that a bad play isn't called. __________________ We are all born ignorant, but one must work hard to remain stupid. Ben Franklin

09-19-2004	#14
HJam72 Hall of Fame Join Date: Aug 2004 Location: Over here. Age: 40 Posts: 10,473 Rep Power: 18004	That's It OK, that's it. Fire the refs, Capers, Casserly, Palmer, the rest of the coaches, DD, Dunta, and anyone else who has an attitude. Nah, just fire that one ref and PUT DD ON THE FREAKING BENCH!

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

09-19-2004	#2
rhc564 Veteran Join Date: Aug 2004 Posts: 173 Rep Power: 9	...get use to it, buddy, it's going to be a long year

09-19-2004	#3
ATX Hall of Fame Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Austin Age: 33 Posts: 9,563 Rep Power: 142	i still don't get that call. it's under 2 minutes and a disputable play, where were the guys who make that decision. fire them now

09-19-2004	#5
texasguy346 Mod Squad Join Date: May 2004 Location: Deer Park, TX Age: 30 Posts: 7,066 Rep Power: 2882	The ref blew the call, but like Fiddy said there is no review for a force out call. It's up to the referree on the field to judge. I don't understand the rule, but apparently thats how the NFL does it.

09-19-2004	#6
thetexanator All Pro Join Date: Aug 2004 Posts: 544 Rep Power: 293	the texans should complain to the league

09-19-2004	#8
texansfan88 All Pro Join Date: Jul 2004 Age: 25 Posts: 880 Rep Power: 0	according to the self proclaimed experts on this board, we really suck so it wouldnt of mattered anyway.

09-19-2004	#11
Reddevil63 Hall of Fame Join Date: Apr 2004 Location: Arlington Age: 28 Posts: 1,253 Rep Power: 12	it was a good catch though

09-19-2004	#12
jacquescas Hall of Fame Join Date: May 2004 Age: 33 Posts: 1,323 Rep Power: 11	I'm happy Carr is making strides, if Davis can't control his fumbling we still have Hollings that is promising. I don't expect more than 5 wins this season.

09-19-2004	#16
Jwwillis All Pro Join Date: Jul 2004 Age: 50 Posts: 610 Rep Power: 9	The way I understood it the Texans couldnt challenge in the last 2 minuets only the officials could. The officials didnt challenge it because the force out rule in un-challengable.

09-19-2004	#17
bossbfan Rookie Join Date: Sep 2004 Age: 34 Posts: 9 Rep Power: 0	As a Lions fan I actually felt a little dirty when the ref blew that call on Andre's catch. I want the Lions to win, but not on bad calls. You still would have had to get the onside kick, plus score another TD, but you should have had a shot at it. I also would have liked to have seen if the Lions could have stopped the Texans at the 1 YD line. I think the worst play of the game was when the Texans went for 2 with like 15min left in the game. That was a BAD coaching decision. Very panicky.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Remove advertisements Sponsored links