Rank the TOP 4 QB's in this years draft - Houston Texans Message Board & Forum

LBC_Justin · 02-04-2006

From this draft who do you think are going the be the best NFL QB's.

This is my personal ranking:

1. Cutler - He has by far the best arm, the quickest release, good vision and did a great job while being on a Teir 2 team against stiff competition. When facing tough competiton in the senior bowl he clearly stood head and shoulders above the rest. I see him being in the peyton manning mold of players.

2. Leinart - Obviously he had the best college career of any QB entering the draft. Proven leader and is very clutch, extremely accurate passer. There are questions about his arm strength.

3. Young - Certainly the most exciting player, he is an amazing runner no doubt about it and a pretty good passer. Given the type of offense Texas ran and how he was used in the offense, he is the biggest risk of the QBs but might have the biggest upside. (I have him and Leinart rated very close, but Leinart proved more in college and has less question marks.)

4. Croyle - Rated high by many draft experts but in my mind he still has way too much to prove. Would be a decent 2nd round pick.

texan279 · 02-04-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by LBC_Justin

From this draft who do you think are going the be the best NFL QB's.

This is my personal ranking:

1. Cutler - He has by far the best arm, the quickest release, good vision and did a great job while being on a Teir 2 team against stiff competition. When facing tough competiton in the senior bowl he clearly stood head and shoulders above the rest. I see him being in the peyton manning mold of players.

2. Leinart - Obviously he had the best college career of any QB entering the draft. Proven leader and is very clutch, extremely accurate passer. There are questions about his arm strength.

3. Young - Certainly the most exciting player, he is an amazing runner no doubt about it and a pretty good passer. Given the type of offense Texas ran and how he was used in the offense, he is the biggest risk of the QBs but might have the biggest upside. (I have him and Leinart rated very close, but Leinart proved more in college and has less question marks.)

4. Croyle - Rated high by many draft experts but in my mind he still has way too much to prove. Would be a decent 2nd round pick.

Prepare to be flamed by the Young lovers for this post...

YoungTexanFan · 02-04-2006

Good to see Young not rated #1 and someone else who likes Croyle. I think cutler is overrated.

My list:

1. Leinart
2. Omar Jacobs
3. Cutler
4. Young
5. Croyle
6. Grabadorskie (sp) qb from Toledo
7. Drew Olson
8. Charlie Whiteherst
9. Guy from Miami OH

My list is not based on Athletes/Players. I ranked them as QB'S

GanadoUHCoog · 02-04-2006

1.Leinart
2.Young
3.Croyle
4.Omar Jacobs
5.Cutler

Texans>Colts · 02-04-2006

Cutler
Leinart
Young
Jacobs

I think most people would think Cutler is the best if he had any talent around him.

Tale Gator · 02-04-2006

What effect (if any) does leinart's knee issue (surgery/ the big brace) have on his draft status? Is that brace purely precautionary or is he needing that thing to play?

YoungTexanFan · 02-04-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by Texans>Colts

Cutler
Leinart
Young
Jacobs

I think most people would think Cutler is the best if he had any talent around him.

Cutler got by on physical talent and luck. He is a great prospect, like Farve. He is a gunslinger, and has little fear or notion that one of his passes could be picked off.

Jacobs appears to be the "dark horse" of the QB class.

Maddict5 · 02-04-2006

1 leinart
2 cutler
3 Croyle
4 whitehurst
5 omar jacobs

only messing- it would be nice to anger a few VY lovers but seriously i would rank young 2/3rd

Long-Spurs-Texan · 02-04-2006

Young
Leinart
Jacobs
Cutler
Croyle

rmartin65 · 02-04-2006

Cytler
Jacobs
Leinart
Young

Sutton=08Heisman · 02-04-2006

Leinart
Young
Cutler
Jacobs

thefuture17 · 02-04-2006

cutler
leinarte
young
jacobs

AustinJB · 02-04-2006

Young
Cutler
Leinart
Jacobs

DominickDavisFan76 · 02-04-2006

I agree with most of ur points made, but ur forgetting that Omar Jacobs through for 41 TDs and only 4ints as a soph. Plus he runs a 4.55, and hes 6'4 with perfect accuracy, but besides my point, who do u think will get omar jacobs, do the texans have a chance.

nunusguy · 02-04-2006

Running QBs:
(1) Young
(2) Jacobs
(3) Cutler
(4) Croyle
*********
Passing QBs:
(1) Cutler
(2) Leinart
(3) Jacobs
(4) Croyle

Dunta_23 · 02-04-2006

Lienart
Young
Culter
Jacobs
Croyle

DominickDavisFan76 · 02-04-2006

Nunusguy just said that omar is the 2nd best runnin QB and the 3rd best Passing QB , which still averages out of him being the best QB in the draft and if the Lions were smart they would pick him up instead of letting Arizona get him and waste more time on Joey Harrington.

DominickDavisFan76 · 02-04-2006

Does anyone think that if Omar does good in the combine that he can get taken in the first round. By what i have heard from some draft experts, Jacobs will be a better NFL Prospect then Leinart does anyone agree on this?

HOOK'EM · 02-04-2006

1.) Leinart

2.) Cutler

3.) Vick

4.) McNeil

5.) Young

BuffSoldier · 02-04-2006

Quote:

Originally Posted by HOOK'EM

1.) Leinart

2.) Cutler

3.) Vick

4.) McNeil

5.) Young

wow

leinart
young
cutler
croyle

02-04-2006	#3
YoungTexanFan Hall of Fame Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 4,788 Rep Power: 653	Good to see Young not rated #1 and someone else who likes Croyle. I think cutler is overrated. My list: 1. Leinart 2. Omar Jacobs 3. Cutler 4. Young 5. Croyle 6. Grabadorskie (sp) qb from Toledo 7. Drew Olson 8. Charlie Whiteherst 9. Guy from Miami OH My list is not based on Athletes/Players. I ranked them as QB'S __________________ The significant problems we face cannot be solved at the same level of thinking we had when we created them.

02-04-2006	#5
Texans>Colts Veteran Join Date: Jan 2006 Age: 40 Posts: 172 Rep Power: 0	Cutler Leinart Young Jacobs I think most people would think Cutler is the best if he had any talent around him. __________________ GO TEXANS!

02-04-2006	#9
Long-Spurs-Texan Veteran Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Southlake, TX Age: 45 Posts: 130 Rep Power: 0	Young Leinart Jacobs Cutler Croyle __________________ *Defense* wins Championships.

02-04-2006	#11
Sutton=08Heisman Veteran Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: H-Town Posts: 163 Rep Power: 0	Leinart Young Cutler Jacobs __________________ "Hey Peyton, how does that dirt taste *****?"- Mario

02-04-2006	#12
thefuture17 Rookie Join Date: Aug 2005 Age: 20 Posts: 79 Rep Power: 8	cutler leinarte young jacobs __________________ Remember this name Chad Lemon future star of the NFL

02-04-2006	#1
LBC_Justin All Pro Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Long Beach, Ca Age: 38 Posts: 805 Rep Power: 10	Rank the TOP 4 QB's in this years draft From this draft who do you think are going the be the best NFL QB's. This is my personal ranking: 1. Cutler - He has by far the best arm, the quickest release, good vision and did a great job while being on a Teir 2 team against stiff competition. When facing tough competiton in the senior bowl he clearly stood head and shoulders above the rest. I see him being in the peyton manning mold of players. 2. Leinart - Obviously he had the best college career of any QB entering the draft. Proven leader and is very clutch, extremely accurate passer. There are questions about his arm strength. 3. Young - Certainly the most exciting player, he is an amazing runner no doubt about it and a pretty good passer. Given the type of offense Texas ran and how he was used in the offense, he is the biggest risk of the QBs but might have the biggest upside. (I have him and Leinart rated very close, but Leinart proved more in college and has less question marks.) 4. Croyle - Rated high by many draft experts but in my mind he still has way too much to prove. Would be a decent 2nd round pick.

02-04-2006	#4
GanadoUHCoog Rookie Join Date: Oct 2005 Age: 27 Posts: 74 Rep Power: 0	1.Leinart 2.Young 3.Croyle 4.Omar Jacobs 5.Cutler

02-04-2006	#6
Tale Gator ________ Join Date: Dec 2005 Location: Mars Posts: 1,089 Rep Power: 14	What effect (if any) does leinart's knee issue (surgery/ the big brace) have on his draft status? Is that brace purely precautionary or is he needing that thing to play?

02-04-2006	#8
Maddict5 Hall of Fame Join Date: Jan 2006 Posts: 5,460 Rep Power: 5499	1 leinart 2 cutler 3 Croyle 4 whitehurst 5 omar jacobs only messing- it would be nice to anger a few VY lovers but seriously i would rank young 2/3rd

02-04-2006	#10
rmartin65 I'm Score Join Date: Jul 2005 Age: 23 Posts: 7,494 Rep Power: 19221	Cytler Jacobs Leinart Young

02-04-2006	#13
AustinJB All Pro Join Date: Jan 2006 Location: Austin, Texas Age: 34 Posts: 592 Rep Power: 10	Young Cutler Leinart Jacobs __________________ You have to play this game like somebody just hit your mother with a two-by-four.-Dan Birdwell

02-04-2006	#14
DominickDavisFan76 Veteran Join Date: Apr 2005 Age: 33 Posts: 377 Rep Power: 9	I agree with most of ur points made, but ur forgetting that Omar Jacobs through for 41 TDs and only 4ints as a soph. Plus he runs a 4.55, and hes 6'4 with perfect accuracy, but besides my point, who do u think will get omar jacobs, do the texans have a chance.

02-04-2006	#15
nunusguy Hall of Fame Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Houston Posts: 8,991 Rep Power: 183	Running QBs: (1) Young (2) Jacobs (3) Cutler (4) Croyle ********* Passing QBs: (1) Cutler (2) Leinart (3) Jacobs (4) Croyle

02-04-2006	#16
Dunta_23 All Pro Join Date: Mar 2005 Age: 30 Posts: 824 Rep Power: 9	Lienart Young Culter Jacobs Croyle

02-04-2006	#19
HOOK'EM Veteran Join Date: Oct 2005 Posts: 379 Rep Power: 8	1.) Leinart 2.) Cutler 3.) Vick 4.) McNeil 5.) Young

Remove advertisements Sponsored links

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode