Originally Posted by thunderkyss
You want to do it position by position??
Eli vs Schaub
I think it's a wash...... many here would tell you Schaub hands down.
Brandon Jacobs... Ahmad Bradshaw... Derrick Ward
Ahman Green... Ron Dayne... Samkon Gado... Darius Walker
again, I know you and most everyone on this board would trade everyone of our backs for one of theirs, But Ahmad & Derrick were unknowns when the season started, and Brandon Jacobs was a question mark. If you they were in Houston, I doubt they would have done much better than our guys did.
Plaxico, Steve Smith, Santana Moss
Andre, Kevin Walter, Andre Davis
I think we have the edge, if we're not even
Let's just say they gave up 28 sacks, we gave up 22. I know that's not the end all be all of talent, but that's what we've used for the last 6 years.
Shockey vs Owen
I think it's even. yeah, Owen hasn't put up those probowl numbers just yet, but I think he's just as talented as Jeremy Shockey.
Strahan...... and a bunch of other guys
Mario...... and a bunch of other guys.
Umenyiora is better, more talented than anything we've got, I won't deny that.
Kiwanuka vs Ryans.... I think it's a wash
Pierce vs Greenwood.... wash
??? vs Orr.. whatever
Ross vs Dunta... again, not me, but a lot of the fans here has Dunta as top 10.
Sam Madison vs Faggins..... I like Faggins. I know, I know... but I like Faggins
Sammy Knight vs CC Brown... I wouldn't trade CC Brown for Sammy Knight. & if I did, I'd want them to throw something else in.
Butler vs Demps... I don't even know who Butler is. But I know who they drafted in '08
Had we made the plays they made.. if we had the schedule, they had. Washington, Philly, Jets, ATL, SanFran, Miami, Detroit, Chicago, Philly, Buffalo, we would have had 10 wins...... and people would be talking about how talented we are.
But we didn't.