Where does Matt rank with QBs in playoffs

[gtexan02]

Originally Posted by GP

And...........again with the "these fans" ****. You did this for "those fans" that you deemed to be worthless for rooting for Mario then turning on him when he left. Now you're doing with Schaub in the place of Mario. The constant? You attack your fellow fans and that's getting so damned old, Tex.

You've become The Fan Sheriff. My gawd, man.

Do you really need to write this in every single thread on the boards? He never even used the phrase "these fans"

[GP]

I'm done with it.

[Texecutioner]

Originally Posted by GP

And...........again with the "these fans" ****. You did this for "those fans" that you deemed to be worthless for rooting for Mario then turning on him when he left. Now you're doing with Schaub in the place of Mario. The constant? You attack your fellow fans and that's getting so damned old, Tex.

You've become The Fan Sheriff. My gawd, man.

Guilty conscience seems to have you uptight and uneasy.

[GP]

Originally Posted by Texecutioner

Guilty conscience seems to have you uptight and uneasy.

Nah, man. I'm done.

I'm bigger than that. So I'm done.

I started to PM you, but it wouldn't matter. Typed it out, erased it.

You're hell bent on tearing fans a new *******. Have at it. They're all yours, King Tex. Do your worst.

[Texecutioner]

Originally Posted by GP

Nah, man. I'm done.

I'm bigger than that. So I'm done.

I started to PM you, but it wouldn't matter. Typed it out, erased it.

You're hell bent on tearing fans a new *******. Have at it. They're all yours, King Tex. Do your worst.

You called yourself out there bud.

[Scooter]

Originally Posted by gafftop

Don't know how to do poll where you can rank from first to last but would be curious where you think MS ranks is relation to the other QBs in the playoffs both AFC and NFC. Sorry if this has already been done.
Brady
Manning
Rodgers
Ryan
Luck
Flacco
Dalton
RGIII
Wilson
MS
Kaepernick
Ponder

Sorry I should start
9 or 10 presently
11 or 12 in future
Just my opinion

well, i'd put him above luck, dalton, rg3, and ponder. in a week we'll put him over brady, flacco, wilson, and rodgers.

[vupac1]

http://profootballmock.com/nfl-qbs-o...-card-bitches/

New QB conversation on facebook, playoff edition..
pretty funny, I liked the original one better

[klockWork]

The only player Shaub goes ahead is Ponder. I see you guys have Kaepernick very low. I have him #4 on the list. I think he's that good. I can easily see him outplay Rogers next week.

[Norg]

Peyton Manning
Tom Brady
ryan mallet
Matt schaub
ravens Backup QB
Joe flacco

:P

[beerlover]

I don't really give a **** just long as Texans win

[The Pencil Neck]

Originally Posted by handswarmer

No way you can put Schaub above Flacco.

Sorry, you just can't.

How many times has Flacco thrown for over 4700 yards in a season? 4500? 4000? Um, never? OK.

How many times has Flacco had a QB Rating over 90? 1 time? OK.

Flacco has the better arm. He's the better athlete. But he's not a better QB. And if you can hit him a couple of times, he gets shaky and starts making bad throws... especially if he's not in Baltimore.

I'd take Schaub over Flacco.

[JCTexan]

Originally Posted by handswarmer

I am aware of ewhata has transpired over the last few games- I was talking about the totality of the last 2 years as far as the defense goes.

Foster has been pretty damn good, AJ and Daniels too....

What is the point mentioning last year? Schaub had Houston at 7-3 last year before he got injured. That was the first year he didn't have a terrible defense. In 2010 Houston had a historically bad defense. There was a period that year where the defense gave up over thirty points every game (7 games straight).

Originally Posted by handswarmer

having AJ hasn't helped Schaub??? Texans defense is pretty good too. Ravens isn't. Yet Flacco wins...

If you're just talking about the last two years then how can you say Flacco just wins over Schaub? Flacco got the Ravens one game further than Houston last year (despite playing a non-Schaub Texans), and didn't Houston have more wins than Baltimore this year? This argument seems inconsistent to me...

Bottom line, this is the first time Schaub has experienced the playoffs. Last year he got injured and previous years the defense didn't do it's job. Does Schaub have what it takes in the playoffs? I honestly don't know, but this week against the Patriots will be his first real challenge in the playoffs.

[TejasTom]

He moved up from 12 to 8.

[gafftop]

Originally Posted by gafftop

Don't know how to do poll where you can rank from first to last but would be curious where you think MS ranks is relation to the other QBs in the playoffs both AFC and NFC. Sorry if this has already been done.
Brady
Manning
Rodgers
Ryan
Luck
Flacco
Dalton
RGIII
Wilson
MS
Kaepernick
Ponder

Sorry I should start
9 or 10 presently
11 or 12 in future
Just my opinion

Just want to be clear, the list above was not put in order.

[2012Champs]

Originally Posted by ckhouston

He is just a sad little girl hiding behind a computer.

Everyone knows it.

and what exactly would that make you? A **** talking teenage boy?

[2012Champs]

Originally Posted by ckhouston

I speak my mind and have very rarely pointed a comment at someone personally unless they did so first to me. So I am a fan who has a strong opinion as a fan. As a man if I say something to anyone I will be more then happy to meet and discuss a possible resolution to whatever seems to be the issue. You see its one thing to have a big mouth and act like a big shot, and entirely different to be willing to back up your comments outside the confines and safety of a computer screen.

I highly doubt you would act in person the way you do here or the other texans board you got banned from. I guess talking **** and telling another person to go get drunk and play on some escalators is something you would do in person too huh? If it is you have issues, if not it seems you too have been bitten by the Im a badass message board thug virus

Originally Posted by ckhouston

In the end though it would better if folks would just discuss football and leave the personal comments out of it. Browse through the threads and you will see more personal attacks here than quality comments on the team. It is the environment that has been allowed to flourish on this board unfortunately.

The way you post and how you come across certainly takes away from the acutal football discussion and adds to the crap that goes on

Originally Posted by ckhouston

If you don't think a player is doing a good job you get called a troll. If someone disagrees with your opinion you get your intelligence questioned. Why not just come back with a counter point and debate the issue or agree to disagree? Instead of calling names and making up lies about other members and asking for people to get banned for their opinion.

Would be a more inviting and productive climate I think.

I dont think anyone calls you a troll simply for the fact that you dont like Matt Schaub. You are beyond rediculous with many of your posts and your hate for Matt makes you blind and thats what drives the responses you get.


Did you get banned from the other board for having an opposing opinion while acting in a mature fashion?

[handswarmer]

Originally Posted by The Pencil Neck

How many times has Flacco thrown for over 4700 yards in a season? 4500? 4000? Um, never? OK.

How many times has Flacco had a QB Rating over 90? 1 time? OK.

Flacco has the better arm. He's the better athlete. But he's not a better QB. And if you can hit him a couple of times, he gets shaky and starts making bad throws... especially if he's not in Baltimore.

I'd take Schaub over Flacco.

i'll take 'What is "I'm in the wrong category?" for $800, Alec'

The question was "Re: Where does Matt rank with QBs in playoffs ?"

I made it big so you could see it....

[handswarmer]

Originally Posted by JCTexan

What is the point mentioning last year? Schaub had Houston at 7-3 last year before he got injured. That was the first year he didn't have a terrible defense. In 2010 Houston had a historically bad defense. There was a period that year where the defense gave up over thirty points every game (7 games straight).



If you're just talking about the last two years then how can you say Flacco just wins over Schaub? Flacco got the Ravens one game further than Houston last year (despite playing a non-Schaub Texans), and didn't Houston have more wins than Baltimore this year? This argument seems inconsistent to me...

Bottom line, this is the first time Schaub has experienced the playoffs. Last year he got injured and previous years the defense didn't do it's job. Does Schaub have what it takes in the playoffs? I honestly don't know, but this week against the Patriots will be his first real challenge in the playoffs.

You got on me for including last year then you went back to 2010? That makes no sense.

Schaub has benefitted from a better running game, better WR and a better defense, yet Flacco has more wins.

[2012Champs]

Originally Posted by ckhouston

This board isn't here for you and I to have personal discussions. If you want personal information from me you can PM me. Lets talk football or just not talk.

I dont need anything from you so we can leave it at not talking until you post something stupid in terms of football and then I will comment


edit: I noticed your neg rep and little rant. Im not sure why you think you getting banned for acting like a fool on another texans message board shouldnt be brought up here but I think it is certainly relevant to how you act on this board as well

[Texecutioner]

Originally Posted by 2012Champs

and what exactly would that make you? A **** talking teenage boy?

Actually he is improving. Lol!

At least he is calling people little girls now. It's better then his typical suicide requests. Lol!