The "Should I accept this trade" thread - Page 5 - Houston Texans Message Board & Forum

**Dutchrudder** · 10-30-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by powda

Im seeking 2 trades in a ppr:

I give:

tom brady
brandon pettigrew

I get:

Philip rivers
brandon marshall
jimmy graham

2nd trade is

I give:

Fred jackson
Greg jennings

I get:

Calvin johnson

Points in both trades add up pretty close. 2nd owner is desperate for rb's and I have a boatload of them. Im desperate for wr. If either of these go thru they'll probably get vetoed but i'd like some opinions...

I personally don't care for Fjax anymore this year, so I would take the 2nd trade if I were you. The first, well it's hard for me to give up Brady. Might depend on who your backup QB is, because Rivers is bad this year. Marshall and Graham are great though, so if you really need a WR and TE, it's probably worth it. If you can get CJ though, I would imagine you don't need Marshall.

**Dutchrudder** · 10-30-2012

Thanks for the input on my trade guys, I'm going to counter with different stuff. No need to trade down a WR. My original offer included Ponder for Matt Ryan as well, since he has RG3, but he countered with that trade.

So now I'm offering:

Ponder, Fjax and Malcom floyd for Matt Ryan, OD and Mike Tolbert.

Playoffs go from week 14-16, so I don't want to start Rodgers @Chicago. Also, Ryan has the Saints during Rodgers' bye week.

SCOTTexans · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by powda

Im seeking 2 trades in a ppr:

I give:

tom brady
brandon pettigrew

I get:

Philip rivers
brandon marshall
jimmy graham

2nd trade is

I give:

Fred jackson
Greg jennings

I get:

Calvin johnson

Points in both trades add up pretty close. 2nd owner is desperate for rb's and I have a boatload of them. Im desperate for wr. If either of these go thru they'll probably get vetoed but i'd like some opinions...

No for the first one, don't trade Brady, for the second Calvin hasn't been having the season everyone thought he was gonna have but that trade doesn't look as bad. He plays some bad defenses so i think i would take this if i had some good RBs

**Dutchrudder** · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dutchrudder

I'm 7-1 in a standard scoring league with no PPR. Got an offer of:

Mike Wallace and Owen Daniels for Fred Jackson and Marques Colston.

I have FJax ans Colston on my squad

QB: Aaron Rodgers, Ponder
RB: Willis McGahee, Adrian Peterson, Fred Jackson, Daryl Richardson
WR: AJ Green, Malcom Floyd, Reggie Wayne, Marques Colston
TE: Dennis Pitta, Dreesen (Fred David went on IR)
K: Matt Bryant
DST: Packers, Broncos

Right now I'm just rotating Floyd, Colston and Floyd into my flex spot. My TEs are weak, and Wallace isn't much of a dropoff from Colston. I'm not sold on Fjax, and I don't really need him aside from AP's bye week. I can get by with Richardson in his spot though. What do you guys think?

Well, this trade has boiled down to Fred Jackson for either Tony Gonzalez or Owen Daniels. I'm thinking Gonzo for Fjax is a good deal, but it leaves me very thin at RB. I'm OK with that, as my season won't be very good if AP or McGahee go down, so I'll go for broke. I just hate the idea of trading a RB for a TE, which is why I was trying to get more out of the deal.

**dc_txtech** · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dutchrudder

I'm 7-1 in a standard scoring league with no PPR. Got an offer of:

Mike Wallace and Owen Daniels for Fred Jackson and Marques Colston.

I have FJax ans Colston on my squad

QB: Aaron Rodgers, Ponder
RB: Willis McGahee, Adrian Peterson, Fred Jackson, Daryl Richardson
WR: AJ Green, Malcom Floyd, Reggie Wayne, Marques Colston
TE: Dennis Pitta, Dreesen (Fred David went on IR)
K: Matt Bryant
DST: Packers, Broncos

Right now I'm just rotating Floyd, Colston and Floyd into my flex spot. My TEs are weak, and Wallace isn't much of a dropoff from Colston. I'm not sold on Fjax, and I don't really need him aside from AP's bye week. I can get by with Richardson in his spot though. What do you guys think?

I wouldn't do that Dutch, it's basically trading Fjax for a mediocre TE and I think you take a step backwards from Colston to Wallace. RB's get hurt all the time, I would rather have the depth.

**dc_txtech** · 10-31-2012

I guess I should have read the whole thread instead of stopping at the end of page 4.

I like Gonzo for Freddie in the spot you're in Dutch, especially if it's ppr.

**Playoffs** · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by powda

I give:
tom brady
brandon pettigrew

I get:
Philip rivers
brandon marshall
jimmy graham

Very good for you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by powda

I give:
Fred jackson
Greg jennings

I get:
Calvin johnson

Good for you.

**Playoffs** · 10-31-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dutchrudder

So now I'm offering:

Ponder, Fjax and Malcom floyd for Matt Ryan, OD and Mike Tolbert.

Pretty balanced exchange, slightly tilted in your favor.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dutchrudder

Well, this trade has boiled down to Fred Jackson for either Tony Gonzalez or Owen Daniels.

Jackson for Gonzo is tilted a bit against you, notwithstanding your strategy.

**gtexan02** · 10-31-2012

Jackson for Gonzo is a no brainer. Gonzo has been the #1 TE this season. Jackson sucks and has CJ Spiller eating carries. DO IT

Reggie Bush and Stevie Johnson for Calvin Johnson

Too one sided?

I could also offer VJax or Reggie Wayne + Bush for CJ

Joeycharp89 · 11-07-2012

Woops, wrong thread.

**Say Watt** · 11-07-2012

AJ Green and Daniel Thomas for Wes Welker and Doug Martin.

My RBs (MJD and Sproles) have been hit by injury so I need another back. I don't think there is a ton of drop from Green to Welker. Thoughts?

Joeycharp89 · 11-07-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Say Watt

AJ Green and Daniel Thomas for Wes Welker and Doug Martin.

My RBs (MJD and Sproles) have been hit by injury so I need another back. I don't think there is a ton of drop from Green to Welker. Thoughts?

AJ Green seems to have improved on an already good rookie season, but trading two top tier WRs and getting Doug Martin on top? I'd say it's worth it.

**dc_txtech** · 11-07-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Say Watt

AJ Green and Daniel Thomas for Wes Welker and Doug Martin.

My RBs (MJD and Sproles) have been hit by injury so I need another back. I don't think there is a ton of drop from Green to Welker. Thoughts?

Go click accept right now.

**Dutchrudder** · 11-07-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Say Watt

AJ Green and Daniel Thomas for Wes Welker and Doug Martin.

My RBs (MJD and Sproles) have been hit by injury so I need another back. I don't think there is a ton of drop from Green to Welker. Thoughts?

Yeah, if you are hurting that bad for RBs and didn't pick up Jennings to handcuff MJD, then do it. You won't get better than that offer.

**Say Watt** · 11-07-2012

Rep to all three of you. Thanks! I felt the same way.

Hopefully this trade doesn't come back to bite me in the ass the way the trade that got me AJ Green and MJD did. In fact, I am actually trading with the same guy that traded me those two guys. I want Doug Martin back and he wants AJ Green. I am a harsh negotiator and demanded Welker if he wants AJ Green.

I tried to get Jennings when MJD went down but of course someone was ahead of me in waivers and snatched him.

**Playoffs** · 11-07-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Say Watt

AJ Green and Daniel Thomas for Wes Welker and Doug Martin.

Strongly tilted in your favor.

**dc_txtech** · 11-08-2012

I'm killing it on trades this season. I traded Demarco Murray for Wes Welker exactly one day before Murray sprained his ankle. I traded The Lawfirm for Stevie Johnson, and now I'm packaging Johnson and R. Bush for Randall Cobb. It's ppr and we get 1 point per 20 return yards so Cobb is the #2 receiver in the league. Here's my roster.

Aaron Rodgers
Wes Welker
Randall Cobb
Danny Amendola
Adrian Peterson
Alfred Morris
Vernon Davis
Matt Bryant
SEA D

Bench:
Torrey Smith
James Jones
Darren Sproles
Michael Turner
Pierre Thomas
Brandon Myers
Josh Freeman (going to pick him up once trade goes through)

Now I just gotta make the playoffs

SCOTTexans · 11-13-2012

Me

Jimmy Graham
Reggie Wayne

Him
Brandon Marshall
Willis Mcgahee
Brandon Pettegrew

My team.
Tom Brady
Wayne, Bowe, Maclin, Floyd, Santana Moss
Matthews, Reggie Bush, Steven Jackson, and Jennings
Graham, Dressen

**Dutchrudder** · 11-13-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by SCOTTexans

Me

Jimmy Graham
Reggie Wayne

Him
Brandon Marshall
Willis Mcgahee
Brandon Pettegrew

My team.
Tom Brady
Wayne, Bowe, Maclin, Floyd, Santana Moss
Matthews, Reggie Bush, Steven Jackson, and Jennings
Graham, Dressen

I don't even understand why you are considering this trade. A top 3 TE and top 3 WR for a slight upgrade at WR and RB? I don't get it. Pettigrew isn't doing that well this season, especially in non-PPR leagues. You would be losing a large advantage in Graham IMO.

**Playoffs** · 11-13-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by SCOTTexans

Me

Jimmy Graham
Reggie Wayne

Him
Brandon Marshall
Willis Mcgahee
Brandon Pettegrew

I think you can get more RB than that for who I think is the #1 TE going forward.

10-30-2012	#82
Dutchrudder COOL BEANS! Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Houston Section: Fort Kickass Age: 28 Posts: 13,723 Rep Power: 77704	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread Thanks for the input on my trade guys, I'm going to counter with different stuff. No need to trade down a WR. My original offer included Ponder for Matt Ryan as well, since he has RG3, but he countered with that trade. So now I'm offering: Ponder, Fjax and Malcom floyd for Matt Ryan, OD and Mike Tolbert. Playoffs go from week 14-16, so I don't want to start Rodgers @Chicago. Also, Ryan has the Saints during Rodgers' bye week.

10-31-2012	#86
dc_txtech Subscribed Contributor Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Round Rock Age: 30 Posts: 2,166 Rep Power: 13136	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread I guess I should have read the whole thread instead of stopping at the end of page 4. I like Gonzo for Freddie in the spot you're in Dutch, especially if it's ppr. __________________ Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos.

10-31-2012	#89
gtexan02 Working? Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Boston Age: 29 Posts: 15,334 Rep Power: 34917	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread Jackson for Gonzo is a no brainer. Gonzo has been the #1 TE this season. Jackson sucks and has CJ Spiller eating carries. DO IT Reggie Bush and Stevie Johnson for Calvin Johnson Too one sided? I could also offer VJax or Reggie Wayne + Bush for CJ __________________ Adios until next season. See you then

11-07-2012	#90
Joeycharp89 Veteran Join Date: Sep 2011 Posts: 153 Rep Power: 649	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread Woops, wrong thread. Last edited by Joeycharp89; 11-07-2012 at 08:30 AM.

11-07-2012	#95
Say Watt Site Contributor Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 6,141 Rep Power: 12158	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread Rep to all three of you. Thanks! I felt the same way. Hopefully this trade doesn't come back to bite me in the ass the way the trade that got me AJ Green and MJD did. In fact, I am actually trading with the same guy that traded me those two guys. I want Doug Martin back and he wants AJ Green. I am a harsh negotiator and demanded Welker if he wants AJ Green. I tried to get Jennings when MJD went down but of course someone was ahead of me in waivers and snatched him.

11-08-2012	#97
dc_txtech Subscribed Contributor Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Round Rock Age: 30 Posts: 2,166 Rep Power: 13136	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread I'm killing it on trades this season. I traded Demarco Murray for Wes Welker exactly one day before Murray sprained his ankle. I traded The Lawfirm for Stevie Johnson, and now I'm packaging Johnson and R. Bush for Randall Cobb. It's ppr and we get 1 point per 20 return yards so Cobb is the #2 receiver in the league. Here's my roster. Aaron Rodgers Wes Welker Randall Cobb Danny Amendola Adrian Peterson Alfred Morris Vernon Davis Matt Bryant SEA D Bench: Torrey Smith James Jones Darren Sproles Michael Turner Pierre Thomas Brandon Myers Josh Freeman (going to pick him up once trade goes through) Now I just gotta make the playoffs __________________ Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos.

11-13-2012	#98
SCOTTexans Veteran Join Date: Mar 2012 Location: Webster Age: 25 Posts: 362 Rep Power: 2614	Me Jimmy Graham Reggie Wayne Him Brandon Marshall Willis Mcgahee Brandon Pettegrew My team. Tom Brady Wayne, Bowe, Maclin, Floyd, Santana Moss Matthews, Reggie Bush, Steven Jackson, and Jennings Graham, Dressen __________________ . . "Do not argue with an idiot. He will drag you down to his level and beat you with experience" Mark Twain

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode