The "Should I accept this trade" thread - Houston Texans Message Board & Forum

**gtexan02** · 09-18-2012

Me: Vincent Jackson
Him: Dez Bryant and Greg Jennings (or Dez Bryant or Greg Jennings)

What say you?

**Dutchrudder** · 09-18-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by gtexan02

Me: Vincent Jackson
Him: Dez Bryant and Greg Jennings (or Dez Bryant or Greg Jennings)

What say you?

I like Jennings the most of those guys. Would have a hard time passing on that, but I would try to improve my bench by getting someone other than Bryant.

**gtexan02** · 09-18-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dutchrudder

I like Jennings the most of those guys. Would have a hard time passing on that, but I would try to improve my bench by getting someone other than Bryant.

I feel the same way, but Jennings hasn't looked good and has been hurt a lot recently.

Jackson had a great game on Sunday..

What to do...

**PapaL** · 09-18-2012

I'm a fan on V.Jax. I think him and Freeman are going to do very well together. I wouldn't make that trade.

SCOTTexans · 09-19-2012

I would keep Vincent... He has Dallas next but then Redskins, Chiefs, Saints, Vikings, Raiders

Thats some weak defenses....

**Shaft75** · 09-20-2012

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My backs suck, Bradshaw who's hurt, Ben Tate, deangelo Williams, Andre brown(recent wire pickup)...
At wr I have Demaryius T, G Jennings, and Stephen Hill.

Mr teX · 09-20-2012

It's a wash imo. all these guys have the same issues..

They all have had trouble in the past answering the bell week in week out..

All of their qb's have other options that can (usually do) overshadow them on any given week

don't be fooled by V jax..dude will be "questionable/out" before you know it

it's an even swap if you ask me..

Mr teX · 09-20-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaft75

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My backs suck, Bradshaw who's hurt, Ben Tate, deangelo Williams, Andre brown(recent wire pickup)...
At wr I have Demaryius T, G Jennings, and Stephen Hill.

Megatron is about to go up against the titans defense next week...they have slow midgets all over their secondary....might want to wait a week before you offer this trade.

**HOU-TEX** · 09-20-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaft75

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My backs suck, Bradshaw who's hurt, Ben Tate, deangelo Williams, Andre brown(recent wire pickup)...
At wr I have Demaryius T, G Jennings, and Stephen Hill.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr teX

Megatron is about to go up against the titans defense next week...they have slow midgets all over their secondary....might want to wait a week before you offer this trade.

Yeah, but look at his RB's. He should probably do the trade for that purpose alone. I think AP's gettin ready to get going. I'd do it, but that's just my opinion

**Shaft75** · 09-20-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by HOU-TEX

Yeah, but look at his RB's. He should probably do the trade for that purpose alone. I think AP's gettin ready to get going. I'd do it, but that's just my opinion

Yeah, my RB's stink. I drafted later in the first round. Plus, it's a traditional ESPN league and a non-PPR. Backs are the main source of points.

**Dutchrudder** · 09-20-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by HOU-TEX

Yeah, but look at his RB's. He should probably do the trade for that purpose alone. I think AP's gettin ready to get going. I'd do it, but that's just my opinion

AP is going against San Francisco this week, so his value will probably drop. Calvin against Tenn ought to have a nice day. Might be able to get more in the trade if you wait until Monday. I'd want AP and MacGahee if possible, just throw in any of your current RBs.

Mr teX · 09-20-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaft75

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My backs suck, Bradshaw who's hurt, Ben Tate, deangelo Williams, Andre brown(recent wire pickup)...
At wr I have Demaryius T, G Jennings, and Stephen Hill.

Maybe i read it wrong, but the bolded underlined is the key there. I read it as:

AP for Megatron straight up or

Megatron for Mcgahee/Crabs & Schaub as a package.

& if the latter is the case i wouldn't do b/c Mcgahee is a tremendous step down from AP & your rb corps isn't improved that much.

**Playoffs** · 09-20-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by gtexan02

Me: Vincent Jackson
Him: Dez Bryant and Greg Jennings (or Dez Bryant or Greg Jennings)

Not sure who gets whom, but I want to be on the Jennings/Bryant side.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaft75

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My rule: Never trade your studs. Megatron = mega-stud.

**ObsiWan** · 09-23-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Playoffs

Not sure who gets whom, but I want to be on the Jennings/Bryant side.

My rule: Never trade your studs. Megatron = mega-stud.

Whut he sed.

**Dutchrudder** · 09-24-2012

In my big money league, my roster currently looks like this:

QB: Eli Manning, Luck
RB: Ray Rice, Andre Brown, Mikel Leshore, Adrian Peterson, Toby Gerhart and Fred Jackson
WR: Antonio Brown, Vincent Jackson, Mike Williams (TB), Malcolm Floyd
TE: Dennis Pitta
K: Matt Bryant
DST: Buffalo

It's a PPR league, so I'm a little thin at WR. Since I now have quite a RB corps, I'm thinking of trying to finagle a trade for a starting WR for one of my RBs. I'm proposing a trade of AP for AJ Green to try to get discussions going. Other possibilities I could trade for are Reggie Wayne, Percy Harvin, Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, etc. I'm thinking a hurt Fred Jackson for the hurt Hakeem Nicks would be great, because the guy who has Nicks also has CJ Spiller. Any ideas on this? I really need another WR.

**gtexan02** · 09-26-2012

I think Adrian Peterson for AJ Green is not a good trade for you, personally.
You've got Ray Rice and then a bunch of maybes at running back. AD and Ray Rice are an awesome 1-2 punch. Don't break that up.

Andre Brown has high trade value right now -- I'd be looking to sell high. As does Mikel Leshore. Fred Jackson for Nicks would be a steal if you could get it

**Dutchrudder** · 09-26-2012

So how about this trade given the lineup above:

I trade Adrian Peterson and (Fred Jackson or Andre Brown) for AJ Green and Matt Forte. (It's PPR)

Thoughts? I need another WR, and getting a stud would be nice. I can wait on Forte, but if he doesn't play for a few weeks, I'll be OK.

**gtexan02** · 09-26-2012

Love it.

powda · 09-27-2012

Do it.

**Playoffs** · 09-27-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dutchrudder

So how about this trade given the lineup above:

I trade Adrian Peterson and (Fred Jackson or Andre Brown) for AJ Green and Matt Forte. (It's PPR)

Thoughts? I need another WR, and getting a stud would be nice. I can wait on Forte, but if he doesn't play for a few weeks, I'll be OK.

AP for AJ is pretty much straight up.

Brown for Forte is lopsided in PPR.

I'd do it.

09-18-2012	#1
gtexan02 Working? Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Boston Age: 29 Posts: 15,334 Rep Power: 34917	The "Should I accept this trade" thread Me: Vincent Jackson Him: Dez Bryant and Greg Jennings (or Dez Bryant or Greg Jennings) What say you? __________________ Adios until next season. See you then

09-18-2012	#4
PapaL Loose Screw Join Date: Sep 2004 Location: Maryland Age: 32 Posts: 8,629 Rep Power: 16635	I'm a fan on V.Jax. I think him and Freeman are going to do very well together. I wouldn't make that trade. __________________ Tried and true, I'm rep'in Texan (Steel) Blue.

09-19-2012	#5
SCOTTexans Veteran Join Date: Mar 2012 Location: Webster Age: 25 Posts: 362 Rep Power: 2614	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread I would keep Vincent... He has Dallas next but then Redskins, Chiefs, Saints, Vikings, Raiders Thats some weak defenses.... __________________ . . "Do not argue with an idiot. He will drag you down to his level and beat you with experience" Mark Twain

09-20-2012	#6
Shaft75 Site Contributor Join Date: Apr 2006 Age: 32 Posts: 3,057 Rep Power: 3440	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread Me: Megatron Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package My backs suck, Bradshaw who's hurt, Ben Tate, deangelo Williams, Andre brown(recent wire pickup)... At wr I have Demaryius T, G Jennings, and Stephen Hill. __________________ 2011 Adopt-A-Texan: #80 Andre Johnson Bullying NFL DB's since 2003!

09-20-2012	#7
Mr teX Hall of Fame Join Date: Sep 2006 Location: Everyone Wants The Throne Posts: 6,279 Rep Power: 11970	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread It's a wash imo. all these guys have the same issues.. They all have had trouble in the past answering the bell week in week out.. All of their qb's have other options that can (usually do) overshadow them on any given week don't be fooled by V jax..dude will be "questionable/out" before you know it it's an even swap if you ask me..

09-24-2012	#15
Dutchrudder COOL BEANS! Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Houston Section: Fort Kickass Age: 28 Posts: 13,714 Rep Power: 77704	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread In my big money league, my roster currently looks like this: QB: Eli Manning, Luck RB: Ray Rice, Andre Brown, Mikel Leshore, Adrian Peterson, Toby Gerhart and Fred Jackson WR: Antonio Brown, Vincent Jackson, Mike Williams (TB), Malcolm Floyd TE: Dennis Pitta K: Matt Bryant DST: Buffalo It's a PPR league, so I'm a little thin at WR. Since I now have quite a RB corps, I'm thinking of trying to finagle a trade for a starting WR for one of my RBs. I'm proposing a trade of AP for AJ Green to try to get discussions going. Other possibilities I could trade for are Reggie Wayne, Percy Harvin, Hakeem Nicks, Victor Cruz, etc. I'm thinking a hurt Fred Jackson for the hurt Hakeem Nicks would be great, because the guy who has Nicks also has CJ Spiller. Any ideas on this? I really need another WR. __________________

09-26-2012	#16
gtexan02 Working? Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Boston Age: 29 Posts: 15,334 Rep Power: 34917	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread I think Adrian Peterson for AJ Green is not a good trade for you, personally. You've got Ray Rice and then a bunch of maybes at running back. AD and Ray Rice are an awesome 1-2 punch. Don't break that up. Andre Brown has high trade value right now -- I'd be looking to sell high. As does Mikel Leshore. Fred Jackson for Nicks would be a steal if you could get it __________________ Adios until next season. See you then

09-27-2012	#19
powda Hall of Fame Join Date: Jun 2004 Posts: 2,198 Rep Power: 24382	Re: The "Should I accept this trade" thread Do it.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode