Weekly Sit/Start Discussion Thread

[Tailgate]

Thought I would start a thread where we could all chime in with suggestions and what not regarding who to start or sit on a weekly basis. A second opinion never hurt anybody right? Or has it?


10 team league, no PPR.

Need 2 starters out of these 4:
-Ray Rice @ Jets
-Ryan Grant @ Philly
-Arian Foster vs Indy
-CJ Spiller @ Miami

Need 3 starters out of this group:
-Anquan Boldin @ Jets
-Percy Harvin @ NO
-Mike Wallace vs. Atl
-Bernard Berrian @ NO
-Johnny Knox vs Det

[JB]

Rice & Foster

Boldin, Harvin & Knox

[Tailgate]

Originally Posted by JB

Rice & Foster

Boldin, Harvin & Knox

Thanks bro... REP! Kind of where I was leanin. Knox needs to step up tho. But didnt want to play Harvin AND Berrian.

[JB]

Originally Posted by Tailgate

Thanks bro... kind of where I was leanin. Knox needs to step up tho. But didnt want to play Harvin AND Berrian.

I think Knox against Det @ home should have a decent day. But no telling with Cutler as QB....

[mexican_texan]

I'd play Berrian. I'm not sure Harvin can think straight.

[Tailgate]

Originally Posted by mexican_texan

I'd play Berrian. I'm not sure Harvin can think straight.

He "should" be fine, and he is way too talented not to play imo.

[Cush]

Start 3 of these 4 at WR week 1...?

Ochocinco
Dez Bryant
Hakeem Nicks
Mike Sims-Walker

I really wanna throw Dez out there and I'm leaning towards sitting Nicks.

[dream_team]

Originally Posted by Cush

Start 3 of these 4 at WR week 1...?

Ochocinco
Dez Bryant
Hakeem Nicks
Mike Sims-Walker

I really wanna throw Dez out there and I'm leaning towards sitting Nicks.

Playing Dez without watching him take an NFL snap yet? And he won't start either and coming back from injury? Big time risk. I'd go with the other three.

[LikeMike]

Originally Posted by Cush

Start 3 of these 4 at WR week 1...?

Ochocinco
Dez Bryant
Hakeem Nicks
Mike Sims-Walker

I really wanna throw Dez out there and I'm leaning towards sitting Nicks.

Ocho and Mike should be no brainers... I´d be temptet about Bryant, but in the end I guess I would sit the rookie and go with the sure thing in Nicks.

Here are my questions: 2 out of these 4:

Chris Johnson @Oak
Jamaal Charles @SD
Ronnie Brown @ Buf
Matt Forte @ Det

And one out of these two:

Brent Celek @GB
Visanthe Shiancoe @ NO

[JB]

Originally Posted by LikeMike

Ocho and Mike should be no brainers... I´d be temptet about Bryant, but in the end I guess I would sit the rookie and go with the sure thing in Nicks.

Here are my questions: 2 out of these 4:

Chris Johnson @Oak
Jamaal Charles @SD
Ronnie Brown @ Buf
Matt Forte @ Det

And one out of these two:

Brent Celek @GB
Visanthe Shiancoe @ NO

CJ & JC & Shiancoe

[dc_txtech]

Originally Posted by Tailgate

Thought I would start a thread where we could all chime in with suggestions and what not regarding who to start or sit on a weekly basis. A second opinion never hurt anybody right? Or has it?


10 team league, no PPR.

Need 2 starters out of these 4:
-Ray Rice @ Jets
-Ryan Grant @ Philly
-Arian Foster vs Indy
-CJ Spiller @ Miami

Need 3 starters out of this group:
-Anquan Boldin @ Jets
-Percy Harvin @ NO
-Mike Wallace vs. Atl
-Bernard Berrian @ NO
-Johnny Knox vs Det

I might be tempted to go with Foster and Grant, Jets run D is scary. Boldin, Harvin, Knox.

[dc_txtech]

Originally Posted by Cush

Start 3 of these 4 at WR week 1...?

Ochocinco
Dez Bryant
Hakeem Nicks
Mike Sims-Walker

I really wanna throw Dez out there and I'm leaning towards sitting Nicks.

I would wait at least a week to see how they're going to use Bryant.

[dc_txtech]

Originally Posted by LikeMike

Ocho and Mike should be no brainers... I´d be temptet about Bryant, but in the end I guess I would sit the rookie and go with the sure thing in Nicks.

Here are my questions: 2 out of these 4:

Chris Johnson @Oak
Jamaal Charles @SD
Ronnie Brown @ Buf
Matt Forte @ Det

And one out of these two:

Brent Celek @GB
Visanthe Shiancoe @ NO

Start CJ every week unless he is hurt. I would propably go with Ronnie Brown, he's a beast when healthy, all signs point to him being 100%, and Buffalo's run D is a joke. Plus I'm still iffy on how the Cheifs will split carries, they did pick up Thomas Jones and draft McCluster.

I like Celek, especially in a ppr league. Shiancoe is always a threat to score a TD though.

[Tailgate]

Originally Posted by dc_txtech

I might be tempted to go with Foster and Grant, Jets run D is scary. Boldin, Harvin, Knox.

I know. Not to mention Bills have named CJ Spiller the starter vs Miami and Fred J and Lynch are both nursing nagging injuries???

[Tailgate]

Originally Posted by dc_txtech

Start CJ every week unless he is hurt. I would propably go with Ronnie Brown, he's a beast when healthy, all signs point to him being 100%, and Buffalo's run D is a joke. Plus I'm still iffy on how the Cheifs will split carries, they did pick up Thomas Jones and draft McCluster.

I like Celek, especially in a ppr league. Shiancoe is always a threat to score a TD though.

Im almost leaning towards Forte and CJ here. Tough call but its Browns first game back and and Ricky had 200 yards and 2 TDs against Buffalo last year. Brown struggled a bit in preseason and Forte has looked like his rookie self. But cant go wrong with either imo.

[dc_txtech]

Originally Posted by Tailgate

I know. Not to mention Bills have named CJ Spiller the starter vs Miami and Fred J and Lynch are both nursing nagging injuries???

Spiller is definitely an option as well, I was lucky enough to pick him up in the ninth round of my money league. That was the night before he had his National coming out party with 2 TD's catapulting him up to the 4th 5th round. I'm going to wait at least one game before I name him my starter though. I wanna see what he can do in the regular season before I make any decisions.

Funny thing though, I have Grant, Foster, and Spiller in my money league so I guess great minds think alike. I'm starting Grant and Foster.

[Tailgate]

Originally Posted by dc_txtech

Spiller is definitely an option as well, I was lucky enough to pick him up in the ninth round of my money league. That was the night before he had his National coming out party with 2 TD's catapulting him up to the 4th 5th round. I'm going to wait at least one game before I name him my starter though. I wanna see what he can do in the regular season before I make any decisions.

Funny thing though, I have Grant, Foster, and Spiller in my money league so I guess great minds think alike. I'm starting Grant and Foster.

[b0ng]

Knowshon Moreno vs JAX
or
Jerome Harrison @TB?

[JB]

Originally Posted by b0ng

Knowshon Moreno vs JAX
or
Jerome Harrison @TB?

Harrison until Moreno proves he is healthy. Buckhalter may get most of the work for Denver in week 1

[dc_txtech]

Originally Posted by JB

Harrison until Moreno proves he is healthy. Buckhalter may get most of the work for Denver in week 1

+1 Moreno is kind of scary with that hamstring right now.