The "Should I accept this trade" thread

[gtexan02]

Me: Vincent Jackson
Him: Dez Bryant and Greg Jennings (or Dez Bryant or Greg Jennings)

What say you?

[Dutchrudder]

Originally Posted by gtexan02

Me: Vincent Jackson
Him: Dez Bryant and Greg Jennings (or Dez Bryant or Greg Jennings)

What say you?

I like Jennings the most of those guys. Would have a hard time passing on that, but I would try to improve my bench by getting someone other than Bryant.

[gtexan02]

Originally Posted by Dutchrudder

I like Jennings the most of those guys. Would have a hard time passing on that, but I would try to improve my bench by getting someone other than Bryant.

I feel the same way, but Jennings hasn't looked good and has been hurt a lot recently.

Jackson had a great game on Sunday..

What to do...

[PapaL]

I'm a fan on V.Jax. I think him and Freeman are going to do very well together. I wouldn't make that trade.

[SCOTTexans]

I would keep Vincent... He has Dallas next but then Redskins, Chiefs, Saints, Vikings, Raiders

Thats some weak defenses....

[Shaft75]

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My backs suck, Bradshaw who's hurt, Ben Tate, deangelo Williams, Andre brown(recent wire pickup)...
At wr I have Demaryius T, G Jennings, and Stephen Hill.

[Mr teX]

Originally Posted by Shaft75

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My backs suck, Bradshaw who's hurt, Ben Tate, deangelo Williams, Andre brown(recent wire pickup)...
At wr I have Demaryius T, G Jennings, and Stephen Hill.

Megatron is about to go up against the titans defense next week...they have slow midgets all over their secondary....might want to wait a week before you offer this trade.

[HOU-TEX]

Originally Posted by Shaft75

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My backs suck, Bradshaw who's hurt, Ben Tate, deangelo Williams, Andre brown(recent wire pickup)...
At wr I have Demaryius T, G Jennings, and Stephen Hill.

Originally Posted by Mr teX

Megatron is about to go up against the titans defense next week...they have slow midgets all over their secondary....might want to wait a week before you offer this trade.

Yeah, but look at his RB's. He should probably do the trade for that purpose alone. I think AP's gettin ready to get going. I'd do it, but that's just my opinion

[Mr teX]

Originally Posted by Shaft75

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My backs suck, Bradshaw who's hurt, Ben Tate, deangelo Williams, Andre brown(recent wire pickup)...
At wr I have Demaryius T, G Jennings, and Stephen Hill.

Maybe i read it wrong, but the bolded underlined is the key there. I read it as:

AP for Megatron straight up or

Megatron for Mcgahee/Crabs & Schaub as a package.

& if the latter is the case i wouldn't do b/c Mcgahee is a tremendous step down from AP & your rb corps isn't improved that much.

[Playoffs]

Originally Posted by gtexan02

Me: Vincent Jackson
Him: Dez Bryant and Greg Jennings (or Dez Bryant or Greg Jennings)

Not sure who gets whom, but I want to be on the Jennings/Bryant side.

Originally Posted by Shaft75

Me: Megatron

Him: AP or Mcgahee/Crabtree/Schaub as a package

My rule: Never trade your studs. Megatron = mega-stud.

[Mr teX]

It's a wash imo. all these guys have the same issues..

They all have had trouble in the past answering the bell week in week out..

All of their qb's have other options that can (usually do) overshadow them on any given week

don't be fooled by V jax..dude will be "questionable/out" before you know it

it's an even swap if you ask me..

[SCOTTexans]

Originally Posted by Dutchrudder

12 team draft, number drafted overall:

Rodgers 1
MJD 18
FJax 34
Manning 47
Reggie Wayne 72
Floyd 105

He also has Lesean McCoy, Stevie Johnson, Jeremy Maclin and Santonio Holmes. All are rather inconsistent, so he's looking to upgrade the WR spot. That's why I'm willing to take the hit at WR and upgrade RB. I was trying to pawn off Colston in this deal originally, which makes it even better for me because he's my lowest performing WR.

I made him a counter of Wayne and Fjax for MJD and Holmes. We'll see what happens, but I think he's set on Rodgers for Manning.

Im not a fan of that trade... but im really high on wayne this yr. He has always been consistent with his numbers every week... holmes is very inconsistent and drops most of his passes (i have him too) i would love to trade him.... so consider this a loss.

On the other hand... MJD is a really good option, but fred jackson puts up really big number when healthy and he should be healthy and scoring big during the fantasy playoffs.

I wouldnt do this trade because i look mainly at the playoffs. Everything else just gets you there.

Wayne>holmes
MJD=Jackson (in the playoffs)

JMO

[Say Watt]

Originally Posted by Mr. White

I need to propose a trade. I'll probably need to trade a RB or TE for a WR and/or QB.

I'm loaded at RB. I've got Rice, Richardson, and Morris.

I'm also pretty good at TE right now with Gonzales and Gronkowski.

I'm weak at WR with D. Thomas and Steve Smith.

My QBs in Cam Newton and Rivers are stinking it up this year.

Does anyone have any idea what QBs and WRs I should be targeting with my guys? I'm totally clueless in this area.

edit- standard scoring

Give us the players on a team you are thinking about trading with.

[gtexan02]

I've got:
Tony Gonzalez and Vernon Davis at TE (#1, #2 scoring TE in my league)
Reggie Wayne, Vincent Jackson, and Stevie Johnson at WR
Bush, Richardson, and Peterson at RB

He's got:
Fred Davis and Martellus Bennett at TE (low)
Brandon Marshall, Mike Wallace , and Mike Williams at WR
McFadden, Forte, and Ridely at RB


Davis is out for the year with an achilles. I feel like theres a way I can trade him Davis or Gonzales and improve either my RB or WR stock at the same time.

I was thinking Vernon Davis + Wayne or Vernon Davis + Jackson for Brandon Marshall

What do you think? Too one sided on my part?

[Playoffs]

Wayne & Davis ~= Marshall in non PPR

[SCOTTexans]

Originally Posted by gtexan02

I've got:
Tony Gonzalez and Vernon Davis at TE (#1, #2 scoring TE in my league)
Reggie Wayne, Vincent Jackson, and Stevie Johnson at WR
Bush, Richardson, and Peterson at RB

He's got:
Fred Davis and Martellus Bennett at TE (low)
Brandon Marshall, Mike Wallace , and Mike Williams at WR
McFadden, Forte, and Ridely at RB


Davis is out for the year with an achilles. I feel like theres a way I can trade him Davis or Gonzales and improve either my RB or WR stock at the same time.

I was thinking Vernon Davis + Wayne or Vernon Davis + Jackson for Brandon Marshall

What do you think? Too one sided on my part?

I wouldn't trade away Vincent or Wayne... the have been as good as any Wr.

[gtexan02]

Originally Posted by SCOTTexans

I wouldn't trade away Vincent or Wayne... the have been as good as any Wr.

Davis + Johnson for Wallace?

Other options include dropping davis and picking up Miles Austin

[SCOTTexans]

Originally Posted by gtexan02

Davis + Johnson for Wallace?

Other options include dropping davis and picking up Miles Austin

That would be the way to go now that the bye week for tony is gone.... I wish either of those receivers were available in any of my leagues.

Both will be good options but i just don't see someone trading Davis for Wallace, if so take it. Austin is a great consolation prize though

[gtexan02]

Adrian Peterson for Calvin Johnson.

Should I do it?

My other RBs are Trent Richardson and Reggie Bush

[Playoffs]

Originally Posted by gtexan02

Adrian Peterson for Calvin Johnson.

AP side is favored, unless PPR then it's pretty fair.

May not be the best move for your team, though.