McShay's 32

[thunderkyss]

What do you think of Tod McShay's top 32 players in the 2012 draft?

1. QB: Andrew Luck
2. QB Robert Griffin III
3. OT: Matt Kalil
4. RB: Trent Richardson
5. CB:Morris Claiborne
6. DE: Melvin Ingram
7. DT: Michael Brockers
8. WR: Justin Blackmon
9. ILB: Luke Kuechly
10. OT: Riley Reiff
11. DE: Quinton Coples
12. S: Mark Barron
13. QB: Ryan Tannehill
14. DT: Dontari Poe
15. CB: Janoris Jenkins
16. G: David DeCastro
17. OLB: Courtney Upshaw
18. TE: Fletcher Cox
19. WR: Michael Floyd
20. CB: Dre Kirkpatrick
21. G: Cordy Glenn
22. WR: Kendall Wright
23. OT: Mike Adams
24. OT: Jonathan Martin
25. DT: Jerel Worthy
26. DE: Andre Branch
27. C: Peter Konz
28. DT: Devon Still
29. QB: Brock Osweiler
30. DE: Chandler Jones
31. RB: Lamar MIller
32. ILB: Dont'a Hightower

[bah007]

Tannehill is not close to the #13 player in this draft. At all.

Now, he may very well get drafted in the top 15. But that doesn't mean he is one of the 15 best players. It just means that a team is wasting a first round pick on a second round QB.

[kiwitexansfan]

QBs overrated, as are Barron and Poe.

[mussop]

QB: Andrew Luck
QB Robert Griffin III
OT: Matt Kalil
RB: Trent Richardson
CB:Morris Claiborne
DE: Melvin Ingram over rated
DT: Michael Brockers Way over rated
WR: Justin Blackmon
ILB: Luke Kuechly
OT: Riley Reiff
DE: Quinton Coples
S: Mark Barron
QB: Ryan Tannehill
DT: Dontari Poe about right for someone with his measurables
CB: Janoris Jenkins
G: David DeCastro under rated
OLB: Courtney Upshaw
TE: Fletcher Cox Over rated. I like his team mate Thompson better. And he's not a TE
WR: Michael Floyd under rated
CB: Dre Kirkpatrick
G: Cordy Glenn
WR: Kendall Wright
OT: Mike Adams
OT: Jonathan Martin
DT: Jerel Worthy
DE: Andre Branch
C: Peter Konz
DT: Devon Still over rated
QB: Brock Osweiler
DE: Chandler Jones Like him but over rated
RB: Lamar MIller
ILB: Dont'a Hightower

[Lucky]

Originally Posted by mussop

TE: Fletcher Cox Over rated. I like his team mate Thompson better. And he's not a TE

Are you referring to Brandon Thompson of Clemson? Because Cox is out of Mississippi State.

Never been a fan of McShay's "scouting". Two guys he is underrating are SoCal DE/OLB Nick Perry and South Carolina CB Stephon Gilmore, both easy 1st round picks.

[Carr Bombed]

He's off his rocker... No way in hell would Blackmon make it past Jacksonville's pick. And he wouldn't make it to their pick to begin with.

[mussop]

Originally Posted by Lucky

Are you referring to Brandon Thompson of Clemson? Because Cox is out of Mississippi State.

Never been a fan of McShay's "scouting". Two guys he is underrating are SoCal DE/OLB Nick Perry and South Carolina CB Stephon Gilmore, both easy 1st round picks.

Yes, I don't know why I keep getting Cox and Branch mixed up.