Originally Posted by ChildressTitanMan
Did you see his post. He said Young is a bust,cut him, take the cap hit & start over. Don't try & take the picking on a Dolphins fan route.
No matter what team he/she supports the comment was plain dumb. I added the spice about the Phins because they have a terrible record of making bad draft choices &/or trading away picks for no gain. Williams,Culpepper,Green etc.
Look around,get out your history books. You don't give up on a QB in year 2 unless he has other issues than his play on the field.
Especially not if he was ROTY in year one.
First of all, ROTY is only awarded to guys "in year one".
He won the ROTY simply because of his rushing abilities and that seems to not be working at all this year. Last year he averaged 6.7 yards per run and had 7 rushing TDs. This year he is averaging 3.9 yards per run and has only 2 rushing TDs.
He certainly didn't win it with a 51.5% completion percentage, 6.2 yards per attempt, and more INTs than TDs passing. He won the ROTY last year inspite of him having a 66.7 QB rating last year.