Originally Posted by Scooter
size, strength, the ability to stand in the pocket with even pro's hanging off of him, mid range accuracy, arm strength, and speed. vince young had far more natural physical talent than manziel. he was dumb as a stump and is a prime example of exceptional talent being enough to win at the college level.
if you're going by college stats, keenum is the current elite, and the kids from texas tech and hawaii have won the last 3 superbowls. david carr is on his way to the hall of fame (ugh i feel dirty writing that).
You're bypassing the level-of-competition metric in making Keenum, et al. elite.
VY had better prototypical size, yes. He was a great "athlete".
Your attribution of Arm Strength and accuracy advantage can't be so easily supported.