Originally Posted by beerlover
Remember the Andre Johnson TD catch against Peterson, perfect position, everything where it needed to be but Andre played it perfectly above the rim & made one of his hall of fame catches. In this case, should that play count against a cornerback or just be chalked up to indefensible?
Indefensible. Sometimes there is only so much the defender can do. He played everything perfectly but it was a perfect throw and pass combo.
The only other option is to take a PI. Hard to say whether the coach would rather have you take the penalty or take your chances on a play where you're in perfect position.