Originally Posted by dalemurphy
You are right about what McNair said in 2006. You are also right in this statement: "Kubiak is not Belicheck, Smith is not Pioli, and Houston is not New England."
All of that became clear to McNair by 2010... McNair believes in Kubiak's philosophy and his system but figured out that Kubiak does not have the cold discernment and special decision-making skills that are unique to some of the great NFL coaches: like Belicheck. That is why he arrested some of the control of the team from Kubiak and gave it to Rick Smith... It was Smith who wanted to go another direction at defensive coordinator after 2008, but Kubiak overruled him and promoted Frank Bush. After the 2010 nightmare, Kubiak was retained as head coach but lost a lot of that GM power... Rick Smith was given it and was the one that wanted Wade Phillips.
I can not prove all of it, but it is clearly that the organization has been running much differently since the 2010 season. There was a "C" change, so to speak. Many of the big decisions regarding core players were made with much more calculation and less "loyalty" than was previously the case. Examples I would cite would be the Demeco Ryans trade, the clear decision to let Mario walk without giving him a real offer, the Winston cut, the Alex Gibb exit, Kevin Walter release, not re-signing Dreessen, etc... Those are things that don't happen, I don't think, if Kubiak is running the show.
To the second part of your statement, "Rick Smith is not Pioli"... that is very true. Pioli was a bit of a disaster once Belicheck wasn't pulling the strings anymore... Rick Smith is a vastly better GM. Pioli was part of a perfect storm- a group of football men that came together at the right moment, in the right situation, and did one heck of a job! And, don't get me wrong, Pioli did a great job! My point is that his ability to succeed at that job is limited to the unique situation he was in. I'm confident you will never see him take over an organization and build it into a success... You saw what happened in KC. He kept trying to patchwork that organization with whatever guys he could get from his time in N.E.- and he had no answers... Anyone that hires Romeo Crennel to be the head coach is clearly at a loss.
No offense DM but this statement is mostly you guessing and everything you are wishing, wanting, dreaming and hoping for along with a good dose of supposition. The reason it all falls it on it's face is Gary Kubiak never gave up full and final control of the 53 man roster. It's part of his contract today just as it was the day it was written. Kubiak's contract has not changed or been redone it still expires in 2014.
Pioli was a very good right hand man for Belichick, Bill could trust Scott to do what Belichick wanted done, in much the same way Kubiak trust Smith to to what Gary wants and needs Rick to do. At KC Pioli did a very good job in player personnel acquisitions and transactions as the 2013 7-0 Chiefs start will attest. Pioli failed miserably in his Head Coach selection.
Little secret here, it was Bob McNair that hired Wade Phillips. That was a done deal in the later part of December when Bob invited Bum to a Texans practice.