Originally Posted by TexansSeminole
You should compare him to other starting QBs in the league to determine if he played well overall.
Well then you're creating your own phantom counter argument.
No one has said that keenum can play like that forever and be considered a good starter.
What has consistently been said is that in those circumstances, with that being his first start he played well. It was a very good beginning for him.
If you are comparing him to other good starting qb's then your expectations were unrealistic. If he'd have played like a good starter having a good game against that defense that would have been unreal. And even then, it'd still have been just one game.