Originally Posted by Rey
Depends on how he looked doing it. If he had that Stat line but made some great throws, made some clutch plays....visually passed the eye test, then absolutely.
Coversely, he could put up stats that would extrapolate to 4000 yards and if he looked like ho-hum Harry doing it, I'd be looking for a franchise guy in the draft.
You should know that stats are on the only thing that matters.