View Single Post
Hall of Fame
Join Date: Jan 2012
Originally Posted by
Lol......Is this Uncle Nate i'm chating with? Why does it matter to
so much what i think of him as a player? what do you have invested in this? my opinion is my opinion & yours is yours...deal with it.
There is no evidence except for his stats...& i've already showed you the disparity in those.
Production & stats are the same thing....but since you keep bringing it up, why do other qb's in similar systems' stats don't count when discussing how "great they were/are? I brought up Case Keenum earlier in this thread & folks damn near had a coronary.
Aside from that, how much of his "production" do you attribute to the system he's in?
....Don't even answer the above question b/c i already know what you're going to say "but.... but they played lesser competition." & by you saying that you are indirectly saying & judging him by the same NFL standard that i am......otherwise, everyone's stats should & would count the same no matter where & who they play against.
never said he wasn't athletic, but since when does that make you a great qb? Vick, VY, Tommie Frazier, Eric Crouch & a whole host of other college qb's produced great stats on the college level &...... were much more athletic than Manziel is...what did it prove on the next level? & these are guys who at least got their teams to National Championship games.
save your retort b/c you sound irrational......like a VY/reggie bush homer.
Are all the heisman voters homers too? Or stat geeks?
View Public Profile
Find More Posts by 2012Champs