Originally Posted by thunderkyss
To me it's like saying Andre Luck is better than Schaub. History doesn't support it, but the feel is going forward, you're better off with the young'n.
Other than that big hit on Schaub, I don't remember seeing many plays from Mays that was much different than what we get from Sharpton. Granted, like '76 I've only gone back a couple of years, but if what I've seen in the last two years is indicative of the play we're getting from Mays.... it's a marginal improvement at best.
I'm not really a fan of the comparison because Luck just played a whole consecutive season. He's fresh on our minds. When I say I can't remember sharpton, I'm not saying that for effect. I literally can't remember him.
But I do understand what you're saying. As far as the film watching, I'm not going there. Some people look one way in some systems then look another way in others. I have not gone back and watched mays and I'm not going to. But I know what type of player he is and I'm glad he's playing for us. I'll leave it there.