Originally Posted by DocBar
AJ doesn't have the TD's to be considered here. I would bet that TD's are a major factor in this. I have a hard time contradicting Carter. He was one helluva receiver. AJ is, too, but has a very distinct lack of TD's.
As others have pointed out, TDs are not the factor here that you seem to think. As for contradicting Carter, the fact that he was a great WR means that he was/is good at things like catching a football and reading defenses. It does not in any way qualify him to make a list like this. To be fair, anyone can make such a list. It's only when you leave a WR like AJ out of such a list that everyone realizes you're an unqualified moron in that particular endeavor.