Originally Posted by thunderkyss
This back & forth between you & I started because you said when Caldwell took over, Flacco played better.
I said I don't know about Caldwell. We've seen Flacco flash a time or two before.
If Flacco comes out inconsistent next season, then we'll know it was more about Flacco's streakyness than it was about Caldwell.
Over the last 5 years, watching the two play, I never doubted that Schuab was the better of the two. Just because Flacco won a Super Bowl doesn't change that for me. He had a helluva run through the play offs, better than Peyton, & Brady both. That doesn't make him a better QB than either of them, doesn't make him a better QB than Schaub.
If he ever got to the point where you can expect him to play like that more often than not, then I'll say he's a better QB than Schaub.
What about the yr before when the Ravens were 1 Evans dropped pass away from the SB? Did you know Flacco's teams have made it to the playoffs every yr? Clutch gene?
Flacco has the clutch gene, Schaub not so much.