Originally Posted by thunderkyss
From another thread.
He definitely belongs in the top 10 conversation. In the last 5 years, only 5 guys have thrown for 4,000 yards in 3 or more seasons & had a QB rating over 92 (with more than 250 atts) in 3 or more years. I think the conversation should start there & round it out with favorites for other reasons.
It's not about potential, what you think they are going to do next year, or an over reaction to a small sample size (6 games). These guys have played the game at a high level for a long time.
Matt Ryan appears to be an up & comer as he's been on both list over the last two seasons.
Stats = loser
Making plays to kee your team in a game and making plays at the end of games = winner. So far Schaub hasn't shown he can make those plays against playoff caliber teams in the clutch, in big games.