Originally Posted by b0ng
The unfortunate bit about getting medical opinions on athletes is that the only guys who are really qualified to answer pointed questions about a players health (aka the guys who have actually seen Ed Reed's chart) aren't legally allowed to talk about such things on public places like internet forums or radio.
While I do not doubt the knowledge of CnD or Dr. First, and I myself believe that we won't be seeing Reed during training camp, all of us are basically guessing. Some are more educated guesses than others, but in the end these are guesses that are based off of heresay, rumors and news articles, and not an actual examination of the player themselves.
Guesses made by Dr. First and CND are educated guesses that are backed up by experience. I wouldn't question their educated guesses.