Originally Posted by Vance87
No, they're just stupid. Indy's list has Peyton AND Luck in the top 5 best picks.
Well in that case, at a minimum, they're being inconsistent. The Luck pick was considered as much of a "no-brainer" as A.J. was when he was picked. Now you could make a very weak argument that there was somewhat of a choice between Peyton and Leaf back then.
But I'm with you, they're just stupid.