Originally Posted by Rey
This conversation started with PN when he talked about Schaubs league leading passing yards in 2009. In 2009 not only did Schaub throw the ball more than anyone else, but he also was not at the top of any other category except Total Yards.
Pay attention. That doesn't mean he sucks or was not good, but what it means is that league leading yardage he put up was the result of other things...Mainly his attempts and the help he had with YAC...
That is just false logic. You don't have to lead across the board. He was solid across the board. He was 4th on completion %, he was 7th on QB rating, 5th on ypa.
This is in order of attempts. If you give Manning an equal number of attempts he is still over 200 yards shy of Schaub. Brady would be 280 yds back. Cutler 1000 yds back. Romo 120 yds back. Aaron Rodgers 120 yds back.
Your YAC argument cracks me up since so many people claim we don't get YAC either because our receivers suck or because Schaub doesn't hit them correctly. Y'all need to huddle up and figure out if Schaub is the YAC king or the YAC killer.